DeanF Posted November 9 Report Posted November 9 (edited) Currently, water blocks make adjacent soil blocks have a moisture of 75%. This results in many players- myself included- enagaging in rather gamey and unaesthetic water block placement in our fields, with water blocks spaced out as in the left side of the graphic below. I propose that single water blocks still work this way but any water block that borders at least two other water blocks should give adjacent soil blocks a moisture of 100% instead. This would incentivize making actual linear irrigation ditches, instead of scattering single water blocks everywhere- see the right side of the graphic. Irrigation ditches would tend to be spaced three blocks apart, I would imagine, because it is effcient for scythe use. (Scythes cut a swath 3 blocks wide.) Ideally, it would also be nice if the moisture levels stacked when they were equal. For instance, two 75%s would make a 100%, two 50%s would make a 75%, and two 25%s would make a 50%. Then those ditches would have 100% moisture in all three blocks between them for efficient scythe use. And actually, I could come up with better- but more complex- methods than that. I kind of like this: Have single water blocks start at 50% moisture instead, and the irrigation ditches start at 75% moisture the way that single blocks do now. But if an irrigation ditch connects to a rivulet or river to provide constant flow then make it provide 100%. I think this would be ideal. There should probably be a maximum distance that connecting to the rivulet or river would provide this bonus- 128 blocks seems reasonable. Maybe 64 instead? And rivulets and rivers themselves should also provide 100% moisture to bordering blocks. Here is a graphic for this version: Of course, the true minmaxers will just dig holes three blocks deep and fill them with water. Which would be ok, we'd just call them "wells". But this would incentivize irrigation ditches for most players. And settlements next to rivers would be desirable, as IRL. Things could get very interesting with things like a water-wheel-powered Archimedes screw lifitng water uphill from a river to irrigate fields. The generous 128 block range isn't really meant for one long ditch- it is to allow more complex systems of ditches. For instance, if those two ditches in the bottom graphic were connected it would be 32 blocks to the furthest end of the top ditch. Edited November 9 by DeanF 2
Marcos Lavizzari Posted November 9 Report Posted November 9 I agree, irrigation is not as intuitive as it could be. This could be a good solution, even more with the "stacking", that way you can design more realistic plantations. Another way could be adding a block called "Irrigation channel" or something, that you can feed it an infinite water source and it would expand across. That way you can plant "unefficiently" with normal water, but spend some materials to make it better.
Recommended Posts