Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

The MIT license has the following text to waive the author or copyright holder of liability:

Quote

THE SOFTWARE IS PROVIDED “AS IS”, WITHOUT WARRANTY OF ANY KIND, EXPRESS OR IMPLIED, INCLUDING BUT NOT LIMITED TO THE WARRANTIES OF MERCHANTABILITY, FITNESS FOR A PARTICULAR PURPOSE AND NONINFRINGEMENT.

However, the terms of use of the Vintage Story Mod DB says the following:

Quote
  • You warrant that the mod contains no harmful or malicious code, no material which is defamatory, bullying, offensive, obscene, or pornographic, and no breach of copyright of any other person.
  • Any license terms contained in the mod itself must be compatible with the terms put forth by Anego Studios.

Does this mean that the MIT license, which asserts that the software is provided without warranty of any kind, conflicts with the terms of the Mod DB, which requires the warranty that mods contain no malicious code, no defamatory material, and not break any other person's copyright (possibly in conflict with "noninfringement")? If it turns out that the MIT license is incompatible with these terms, what would be a license compatible with the Mod DB's terms that grants users permission to modify and redistribute the mod?

Posted
8 hours ago, Isif said:

Does this mean that the MIT license, which asserts that the software is provided without warranty of any kind, conflicts with the terms of the Mod DB, which requires the warranty that mods contain no malicious code, no defamatory material, and not break any other person's copyright (possibly in conflict with "noninfringement")?

My understanding is that the MIT license is fully compatible with the Terms of Use.

  • Generally, provided that the license attached to the mod does not make it strictly impossible to apply the rules of the Mod DB, they are compatible even if they do not state the same terms.
    • The MIT license does not in any way prohibit the copyright holder from taking on additional contractual obligations and warranties.
    • The Terms of Use do not require that the license contains particular provisions - they only require that the author agrees to certain conditions and provides a warranty.
  • The relevant part of the Terms of Use is strictly applicable to submitting a mod to publish it on the Mod DB, and as such is separate from the license attached to the mod which applies to anyone obtaining a copy of the mod through any means, including from outside of the Mod DB.

Also, fun fact: there are mods created by Anego's developers themselves (e.g. CreativeHotbar) which use the MIT license.

  • Like 1
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.