-
Posts
61 -
Joined
-
Last visited
Recent Profile Visitors
The recent visitors block is disabled and is not being shown to other users.
VANTABlack2000's Achievements
Copper Caster (5/9)
70
Reputation
-
Worries about Maltiez still being on the Development Team
VANTABlack2000 replied to AtomicWinter's topic in Discussion
Considering things like Anego still letting people access the game after refunding I trust Tyron to uphold that statement more than I do most studios. -
Worries about Maltiez still being on the Development Team
VANTABlack2000 replied to AtomicWinter's topic in Discussion
AH see I haven't seen that statement, so I wasn't aware of that. That DOES give me even more trust in Tyron. -
I don't know about sizable number of people I just know I am in that boat. I can understand using Discord, but the exclusivity is what gets me. As well as the fact the forums just don't really feel like the OFFICIAL way to get knowledge when stuff like this is Discord Exclusive though the forums is connected more to the game since it's part of the site than Discord which is more a community relying on another company. Discord is great and all unless you don't like Nitro and all the ads, but I wish the forums felt more like the official way to get information. I will probably try the pre-release and just have one big world I keep updating as the game goes through pre-releases unless that turns into a problem. I can't wait to try out all the new stuff.
-
Worries about Maltiez still being on the Development Team
VANTABlack2000 replied to AtomicWinter's topic in Discussion
I did forget they did that. That is a good way to kind of extend an olive branch since it does prove they aren't like other companies that would just remove all access to the game because of a refund. Every since things smoothed over I have gotten the vibe from the whole thing that Anego just messed up because they haven't really had to DO something like this to my knowledge. They tried, but weren't the best at PR (Which is something they are trying to improve on now) which is understandable because it's not like they are a big studio like Microsoft who has whole departments dedicated to this kind of thing. I do still believe they want what is best for players not just trying to make their money like other studios would. -
Worries about Maltiez still being on the Development Team
VANTABlack2000 replied to AtomicWinter's topic in Discussion
Yeah that sounds about right. As someone who got caught up in the mob of all the Maltiez stuff that went on while I have some worries about him being on the dev team I trust Anego to make sure everything is good. While there are some things I wish were done better like most info being on Discord or Social Media as opposed to the Forums I think everything is in a good spot when it comes to Maltiez. At least personally if I were to not play the game anymore it wouldn't be the Maltiez situation that makes me quit. It does worry me a little bit that you need to login to Vintage Story in game to access it because I am the type of person who worries about servers shutting down or businesses just killing a game, but I trust Anego to not be that kind of dev. I am also not 100% sure how Anego is with GenAI/LLMs which is something that strikes a nerve with me, but again I trust Anego more than I do most studios. The Maltiez drama mainly boils down to Anego doesn't know how to deal with dramas which is something they want to improve now, so like I said before I don't think it is the biggest issue for the studio especially since there is A LOT less talk about it than there was before. People still talk about it from time to time, but it's more of a "Yeah it happened, but it wasn't really that big of a deal" kind of thing now. -
I mean i don't know if it's fair to say meet AI shills in the middle. AI shills are the ones on the other end of the extreme. I think shill is a little harsh for people who don't want to ban it because others find it useful and are trying to appeal to everyone. I can understand why some people just don't understand why some people hate AI so much, so it's better to just try to give them our perspective and not throw out insults unless they start insulting first IMO. I guess it's technically meet AI shills in the middle, but of course when one person is trying to limit something and the other wants it to be free the one trying to limit it is going to struggle.
-
I am not sure how enforceable this is because where is the line on "Primarily" AI Generated, but I do like the idea of having a limit on AI generated content. I personally would prefer a ban, but that's because I hate AI with a burning passion. Taking the middle of the road in terms of GenAI and trying to put a limit at least is better than doing nothing though. I can agree with people who say "Have a disclosure, so those who want to avoid it can" which at least makes it easier for me to avoid AI mods.
-
VANTABlack2000 started following NetBSD
-
I well aware it's a never ending journey. Even just learning coding it's a never ending journey because things are always getting updated and there's so many languages to learn. For some you may be right about why they hate AI. For ME it's a few things 1. Because I value the effort and emotion put into art and AI has no concept of emotion and it's very little effort to just write a prompt and get it done. 2. Because I believe in people's ability to learn and there have been many studies like this one https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/publication/the-impact-of-generative-ai-on-critical-thinking-self-reported-reductions-in-cognitive-effort-and-confidence-effects-from-a-survey-of-knowledge-workers/ that say using AI leads to decreased critical thinking skills. 3. As I have said before I am not a huge fan of corporations, so I really don't like the idea of outsourcing your intelligence to a big corporation hyping all this up like OpenAI or Anthropic. 4. A lot AI use leads people to believe THEY made a thing when really it was the AI that took all the knowledge and made the program they really didn't DO much of anything it was the AI that did most of it and as outlined above it did it using the code of actual people in most cases without any attribution to themselves. the AI did most of the work and the person using it takes most of the credit in a lot of cases. 5. I have studied and made Ai and Machine Learning algorithms, so I know how basic AI works even if I don't know entirely how LLMs work I know enough of the basics to get the idea. I also know that there are things AI is better being used for and things that would be better off not being focused on. For example where is all the data analysis for studying weather patterns or trying to cure diseases instead of "Hey AI can you make this game for me because I don't feel like learning how to do it myself?" All of this is leading people using AI to act like they are better than people actually making their own art and pushing actual artists down which as AI becomes more prominent has a MAJOR effect on the mental health of artists like me, so yes there are many reasons people hate AI and doesn't boil down to "Well now people can do things cheap" which mind you is false when AI gets more expensive to use because of not only computer costs, but the cost of AI subscriptions or token usage goes up as well and making things mostly takes time whenever there is FOSS like Krita, Blender, and Godot to make it free to have your own programs. All it takes is time to learn. Then again a lot of people pushing AI love to think they are so smart and everyone else has no idea what they are talking about. AI is being used in so many places to push out people who are actually putting their heart and soul into projects and people are going "Well AI did it just as well, so use it or get left behind" I see my code as art because I know the effort it took to make it. I know I can do better and I STRIVE to do better, but that doesn't diminish all the work that went into me making my code. The latest example of me doing Art, Programming, and Music (Though the music is a cover of another song in Pico8 and I never say it's not) is my Pico8 game https://www.lexaloffle.com/bbs/?tid=160202 if you have Pico8 you can analyze the game yourself to learn how to do things on your own too. Knowing you can do better does mean that what you make isn't art. Again sorry mods for the walls of text and getting heated, but this is a topic that touches a nerve for multiple reasons. I could go on MANY rants, but needless to say there is a reason I don't want to support AI in the slightest. This will be my last post on the topic because at this point I don't think the conversation is being had in good faith.
-
You are making A LOT of assumptions here. 1. I literally studied Computer Science and though I don't do software development as a job because I hate corporations and all the jobs now either require insane amounts of experience or to use Claude or whatever which I have laid out my problems with I DO know how to code and I DO know how to use Git and GitHub. 2. YOU MADE the correlation between Code being art, and code being needing to be published. If this is a mod argument and saying that the code needs to be published to make sure it's not malicious OF COURSE I agree with you because there was LITERALLY A DRAMA FOR THIS GAME about code being considered malicious by some not too long ago. What at this point do you just assume I don't know what I am talking about in the slightest because I am against AI? I am both a programmer and an artist that IS possible. Part of the reason I hate AI is because I KNOW what goes on behind the curtain and I know the result of it. GenAI like ChatGPT was trained by scraping people's works off the internet at mass scale to generate whatever it wants removing people's jobs and removing the soul from the art and just making an image that is the average of what it scraped. It is the average of everything it scraped because it all boils down to WEIGHTS it looks at the weights of what most likely fits the prompt and makes something based off of it. Also as for your image there is more to it than JUST know this equation. Color theory has to be used for picking the colors of the image you made as well. Not to mention does that equation make the background too? You may not consider stealing, but I am sure there are MANY artists like me that do when the purpose of using their art without their permission is to replace them and corrupt their craft like I outlined above. Mods if I am getting too heated in this let me know because naturally AI is a very touchy subject for me.
-
I think you are missing the point in multiple regards. 1. Even with the printing press you can still hand write things and then print it to make it multiple times. With AI using the EXACT SAME prompt doesn't result in the exact same output. It's all a randomization machine that is fooling people with smoke and mirrors. The printing press also doesn't rely on stealing the works of people to do literally anything unlike AI. Because of the requirement to write something before you print it too it doesn't degrade skills or prevent learning like AI does. 2. Not all art needs to be published. Just because I see code as a creative work doesn't mean it should be banned to not publish it. IMO Most people who make art has unpublished work, so I don't know where that statement even comes from. I am merely saying that AI removes an artistic aspect from a mod even if it is used for coding. It also REMOVES learning opportunities because it is just loaning off your intelligence to a machine (That as I mentioned above is also just smoke and mirrors and isn't really intelligent at all) you are better off trying to either learn coding or find someone to help with the coding.
-
As much as personally I would like a ban on AI mods I think the best thing is a filter for people to find mods that aren't made with AI if they wish. I agree that a greenlight system like that just wouldn't work well. For a game store that might work, but for a community project like VS mods that doesn't sound like a good idea.
-
I am with you. AI IMO is the opposite of art and art is about the passion and effort that is put into a creative work. The time and effort makes it all the better.
-
At least to me the difference between AI and The Printing Press is that while The Printing Press allows you to make things faster by printing them making it cheaper to produce. AI is an algorithm that "learns" by stealing from other people then puts that through a randomization algorithm to get something that LOOKS good, but is never consistent. This means people using AI aren't learning as much HOW to do things and part of the art of the craft is lost. Which is why at least personally I don't like the idea of ANY part of a mod using AI because I see Art in everything down to the code itself. If you put in the time it's possible to learn all 3 between coding, art, and audio I have dabbled in solo game dev myself. What REALLY democratizes coding and other aspects of Game Dev is Open Source Software (OSS) and especially Free Open Source Software (FOSS) which allows people to get tools much easier to make mods and having good tutorials on how to create mods democratizes development. AI just works like a drug to get you hooked and next thing you know if you aren't careful you are using it as a crutch. It's like outsourcing your brain to get something done fast. That's my opinion the matter at least though if it wasn't clear I am very biased against GenAI and LLMs.
-
This is the sort of thing I wonder how much of it is ModDB and how much of it is certain browsers if that makes sense.
-
When you go to run the world does it say anything about running in repair mode? I have had worlds corrupt because I forgot to do something on the menu and canceled the loading screen and then when I try to go back on it gives me that prompt. Other than that I would check to see if there are any world backups somewhere as well you may be able to use to at least get most of your progress back.