If we talk purely about logo design, none of them are what we can call a « good » logo (I say that without any negativity I don’t want you to think this is a mean comment).
Usually a logo is to be simple, readable at any scale, without too much details (to ensure the previous point remains relevant). A good logo should be distinct and recognizable, conveying key aspects about what it represents. Not everything about the game has to be present in the logo to achieve that and yes, it is a difficult task to make a logo.
Personally none of them appeal to me, even though I voted for the new one because it is a little bit clearer and easier to read.
Good luck with the new visual identity !
