Zorkman

this is nice, i really enjoy this take for a tree-centric design

understandable, though i reiterate that this was only done as a fun design exploration. any real designing to be done in any capacity is purely on the devs i'd imagine

thanks also. my drawings are really not a serious suggestion and were only for fun, but i'm glad to hear i managed to make something that works somewhat lmao but also i forgot factorio was a thing (it's so over)

thanks. as for the flowers, the reason they're so simple is to not overcomplicate it and mostly just imply their shape from a distance. felt wrong to NOT have something there on the green otherwise

i'm seeing a variety of suggestions and vibe assessments here, and i almost find it more fascinating how Vintage really evokes different feelings for different folks. my own opinion on the matter is thus: i think both the old one and the new one are very elaborate, which from a logo design perspective could get kind of iffy. i read the grievances of the logos being more illustrations than something iconographic which i can understand, but i also think that kitsch and busy designs CAN be done right if they focus the implemented detail in the right ways. the old one has a rustic charm to it by this point, the new one is a very different stylistic take but a better overall silhouette and text placement. a mix of the two could be interesting assuming that the idea is to keep the design identical thematically, what with the tree and all having said that, i don't think these designs would really be a good fit for a desktop icon specifically unless they were tinkered to look good at a distance. for that, i think the gear designs people have been positing would honestly be a very good direction to go down, i quite like the focus on that as a thematic and design element made my own fun little mockups as to how i'd personally go about it, because it seemed like a fun design challenge

felt inclined to cobble together some fan scribbles in an aggie.io session based on a multiplayer run i'm doing with two friends. game's pretty fun (even if a little complicated for someone with a tiny brain like i)