Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

Temporal rifts are one of the most unsettling and mysterious phenomena in Vintage Story. I think we all had a mysterious and threatening feeling the first time we saw one. The visual and sound design really manages to convey the idea that something bad is going on there.

However, once the player understands how they work, rifts usually lose much of that initial impact. In practical terms, most of them end up being something we just watch for a few seconds before moving on.

That's why I would like to propose a relatively simple idea: a tier system for temporal rifts, which affect their visual size and mobs spawns.

Tier 1 Rifts:

This are the smallest rifts, just like the ones we already have rigth now. They are also the most common.

- T1 rifts can spawn T1 drifters.

- T1 rifts size (and spawn range) is the smallest one.

-T1 rifts have the lowest spawn rate.

- Rarity: Very common.

Tier 2 Rifts:

- Bigger than the T1 rifts. Size, spawn rate and spawn range are slightly increased.

- T2 rifts can spawn T1 and T2 drifters.

- Rarity: Common.

Tier 3 Rifts:

- Bigger than the T2 rifts. Size, spawn rate and spawn range are slightly increased.

- T3 rifts can spawn T1, T2 and T3 drifters.

- Rarity: Rare.

Tier 4 Rifts:

- This would have a notorious size, which also means a prety big spawn range.  

- Bigger than the T3 rifts. Size, spawn rate and spawn range are slightly increased.

- T4 rifts can spawn T1, T2, T3 and T4 drifters.

- Rarity: Very strange.

 

The main goal of this suggestion is not to increase difficulty, but to give temporal rifts more visual presence and atmosphere, while also making the world of Vintage Story feel more alive, mysterious, and unpredictable.

Imagine walking through the wilderness at night and spotting a massive rift in the sky on the horizon, far larger than any ordinary rift, with drifters gathering beneath it.

You wouldn't necessarily have to approach it or fight anything. In fact, simply seeing it from a distance could be enough to create tension, curiosity, and memorable moments.

Temporal rifts are one of the most mysterious and unsettling phenomena in Vintage Story, but currently they do not feel as impactful as their appearance suggests. I believe giving some of them a greater visual impact would help them feel as important and threatening as they appear to be.

* There are still some details that would need to be defined with this suggestion. For example, how temporal stability loss would work for each rift tier. Would all rifts reduce stability at the same rate, or would larger rifts affect stability from a greater distance?
Posted

What about shivers and bowtorn?

That's my main problem with the tier table: rifts spawn all three kinds of rotbeast, not just drifters. What does each tier do to shivers and bowtorn? They're gated the same way. There's a surface shiver and a surface bowtorn, and heavier variants further down.

Which leads to my real objection: rotbeast tier is currently tied to depth. Deeper means nastier, and on the surface only surface drifters spawn at all, and only within 25 blocks of a rift. If rift tier decides what spawns, a big rift can drop deep-tier rotbeasts on a player who's still trying to find copper. That's a difficulty change however it's framed, which you explicitly said you didn't want. See below:

2 hours ago, Vintage Darius said:

The main goal of this suggestion is not to increase difficulty, but to give temporal rifts more visual presence and atmosphere, while also making the world of Vintage Story feel more alive, mysterious, and unpredictable.

If the goal is atmosphere rather than difficulty, you can get most of it without touching rotbeast tiers. Let rift tier scale the visuals, the spawn radius, the spawn rate and the stability drain, and let the biggest rifts be the rare ones, turning up at high rift activity or far from spawn. Then a huge rift on the horizon reads as a warning rather than a level gate. Worth remembering that rift activity already multiplies spawn rates for all supernatural enemies game-wide, so stacking a second tier on top could compound quickly.

  • Like 1
Posted

It's an interesting idea, but I don't really see how this makes rifts more interesting or mysterious, as much as it does make them even more of a nuisance and prompt players to turn them off. There's a reason that rifts only spawn surface level opponents(ie, tier 0)--in the early game, that's about as much as the average player can really handle, and they'll usually struggle a bit even with that. Dumping a nightmare enemy on the player in the early game is just not going to go well, and I don't see many players being satisfied with the excuse of "Oops, you just got unlucky. Better luck next time!" It's a memorable moment for sure, but not the good kind of memory.

That issue can, of course, be fixed by restricting "high tier" rift spawns to later in the game, after a certain number of days have passed and the player has had plenty of time to equip themselves. However, I don't think it's a complete fix since, well, it's still a nightmare level enemy that one has to deal with on the surface outside of temporal storm conditions or special locations. A bear or other tough wild animal is one thing, since a world will naturally have dangerous wildlife to encounter. But the monsters decidedly aren't natural, so getting one randomly dropped on your head in an area that's supposed to be free of them probably isn't going to be taken well.

1 hour ago, Teh Pizza Lady said:

Which leads to my real objection: rotbeast tier is currently tied to depth.

Depth and temporal storm strength. 

And then, of course, there's the issue of mega-rifts making the impact of temporal storms and a certain story location much less intense. Especially the story location. The reason it hits as hard as it does, is that prior to visiting it, the player hasn't witnessed anything remotely that bad, and gets to see it looming on the horizon for quite a while before they actually get there to see what's going on.

Posted (edited)

 

13 hours ago, LadyWYT said:

Depth and temporal storm strength.

Fair correction, and I went and read the code rather than the wiki, so I will happily amend my claim: rotbeast tier is not depth only. But I do not think "depth and temporal storm strength" is quite right either, because during a storm depth stops mattering at all, and when there is no storm, light level is doing half the work. What 1.22.7 actually does:

Outside a storm, tier is a Y band plus light level, and there is no storm input anywhere in the spawn data. The drifter spawn conditions carry maxLightLevel 7, minYByType and maxYByType bands for normal through nightmare, and "*-double-headed": 0, so the ambient spawner is not allowed to spawn that one at all. Shiver and bowtorn use the same pattern. Light is a second gate here, not just depth, since we're being precise at this moment.

During a storm, strength feeds straight into which variant spawns, and that path does no Y check at all. TemporalStability.cs, trySpawnForPlayer, line 571:
float typernd = (stormStr * 0.15f + (float)api.World.Rand.NextDouble() * (0.3f + stormStr / 2f)) * variantGroup.Length;

The roll walks up the variant ladder as stormStr rises, and the spawn point is just a random offset around the player, with no Y test in the method. Line 555 of the same method:
int allowedCount = (int)Math.Round((2 + stormStr * 8 ) * group.Value);

...so a stronger storm also spawns more of them. That is the mechanism behind more powerful varieties on the surface.

But it is a probability shift, not tiers per storm strength. Strength itself is 0.53, 0.67 or 0.9 plus up to 0.1 (lines 384 to 386), so light and heavy are about one variant step apart on average, not a category apart. If anyone wants light to mean only tier 0-2, medium to mean 1-3, and heavy to mean 3-4, that is a change worth suggesting, and I would support it, maybe, as a mod, lol.

Two things you shouldn't confuse with strength:

  1. which species you get (drifter, shiver, bowtorn weights) is a spawn pattern chosen per storm, independent of strength
  2. rift activity multiplies quantity caps, not tier.

And it's been this way since 1.20, pretty much because that's the last time that bit of code was updated.

TL;DR: I was wrong that rotbeast tier is depth only, but "depth and storm strength" is not the fix either: outside a storm it is depth plus light, and during a storm it is storm strength instead of depth, working as a probability shift rather than tiers per storm strength. Nasties can still spawn during a light storm, at about one roll in seventy for nightmare tier if the math checks out.

13 hours ago, LadyWYT said:

And then, of course, there's the issue of mega-rifts making the impact of temporal storms and a certain story location much less intense. Especially the story location. The reason it hits as hard as it does, is that prior to visiting it, the player hasn't witnessed anything remotely that bad, and gets to see it looming on the horizon for quite a while before they actually get there to see what's going on.

I disagree. My initial response to it wasn't, "oh this is a giant rift. woah", it was, "okay this is bad". I had to be told it was a rift for it to sink in.

Which is the "show, don't tell" problem in miniature. The game never shows you what that place is. Where it comes closest to saying, it says it in a chat message rather than in the landscape, and everything else you have to look at is fog and ruin. Nothing in the approach tells you by sight that this is the same phenomenon as a rift, just at a size you have not met yet.

That is also why I do not think this dilutes the impact of seeing the story location for the first time. What made it land for me was not the size and shape, it was realizing what it was. A player who has already watched rifts scale up has somewhere mentally to put the story location, and the moment it lands is the moment they connect the two, which is the exact moment your argument depends on and is lacking.

So, bigger rifts, yes, but as a connecting piece rather than a spectacle all on their own.

Edited by Teh Pizza Lady
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.