Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted

First of all, hello everyone! 🙂

 

Secondly, so far I love this game. It's very cozy, the gameplay is fun and the visuals and sound creates a very immersive atmosphere.

 

I'm still very early on, just foraging, building a basic house and growing my first crops for winter. But something that immediately felt quite clunky was the inability to do some simple composting in this early stage of the game.

I have spent an ungodly amount of time composting in real life, especially during a particular period of my life when I transformed an entire large backyard into a vegetable garden. When starting a new vegetable garden often the first thing I do is build a compost, not only for all my kitchen scraps, but for all the grass and vegetation that I'll be removing for the vegetable garden.

So accordingly the current early phase of farming just feels quite off in that regard, because this very natural feeling process is missing, which definitely took away from the otherwise generally impeccable immersion everywhere else in the game.

I think the early game would really benefit from a crude compost bin made from sticks, similar to the wattle fence, with an output that is nerfed compared to it's higher tech counterparts. An additional nice touch would be to require the player to protect the compost bin from rabbits, pigs, etc, just like the crops.

This last point would really make it feel realistic; my earliest composts IRL were constantly being picked at by mice and possums, until I learnt the how to make sure the gaps between the wooden planks were wide enough to plenty of air in for the thermophilic reaction, but narrow enough to keep out the mice, so a compost made with sticks would definitely be targeted by pests.

  • Like 3
Posted (edited)

personally, I think the inability to really mess with soil nutrients until you get some kind of metal is just the natural progression of the game and its farming mechanics. you won't be able to craft the best soil of the game until you advance either; and its expensive!! its my main and usually only use for compost, using it as a temporary soil boost over a permanent one feels like a waste when I'm in charge of farming

i don't think this is a bad idea though, a lot of people want the stone age to have more versatility, and for the farming to be more complex, something like these suggestions would add to it.

edit: oh and welcome to the forums!!!

Edited by Demoncyborg
  • Like 1
Posted

Welcome to the forums!

On 11/1/2026 at 8:01 PM, v4u6h4n said:

I think the early game would really benefit from a crude compost bin made from sticks, similar to the wattle fence, with an output that is nerfed compared to it's higher tech counterparts. An additional nice touch would be to require the player to protect the compost bin from rabbits, pigs, etc, just like the crops.

Or just allow a "clay barrel" and "clay bucket" that hold less than their counterparts that are locked behind metal. That way the player has options for making compost, leather, and transporting liquid in smaller quantities, but can't really mass-produce stuff with any efficiency or create water sources(if the setting is even enabled) until they'd gotten a grasp on metalworking. 

Incidentally, the Clayworks mod adds a clay barrel that holds 40 units of stuff and works just like a regular barrel, in addition to adding more to ceramics in general.

Posted

Hey!

16 hours ago, Demoncyborg said:

personally, I think the inability to really mess with soil nutrients until you get some kind of metal is just the natural progression of the game and its farming mechanics.

Yeah I see what your saying... I think perhaps, again taking inspiration from the real world, that natural progression might be retained by adding a simpler compost recipe. In early agriculture fertiliser, to the extent that it even existed, was likely food and vegetation waste, with the addition of special materials, like manure, nightsoil, ash, bone, etc, coming at least a few thousand years later. So an additional compost recipe that fits that historically more simply form of composting could be 18x compost = 1x high fertility soil, or something similar?

1 hour ago, LadyWYT said:

Or just allow a "clay barrel" and "clay bucket" that hold less than their counterparts that are locked behind metal.

That's a good point. I guess the one issue is that it would still leave me with a similar, but less extreme, version of the same problem. Historically, composting was so easy that early farmers would have noticed that they accidentally created fertiliser by heaping their waste in the same place, because seeds in their waste piles were sprouting and thriving (tomato plants definitely sprouted out of my IRL compost piles from time to time). So given this reality, I think even clay barrels would probably still leave me asking "why can't I just make a dodgy ass compost bin and put some leaves in it!?" Hahaha

Posted (edited)
On 11/2/2026 at 3:01 AM, v4u6h4n said:

An additional nice touch would be to require the player to protect the compost bin from rabbits, pigs, etc, just like the crops.

Animals being attracted to crops is a flawed mechanic which should be either disabled or fixed, mainly due to the lack of any sort of proper pathfinding - until that happens, I wouldn't want the same behavior to be triggered by compost.

 

16 hours ago, v4u6h4n said:

Historically, composting was so easy that early farmers would have noticed that they accidentally created fertiliser by heaping their waste in the same place, because seeds in their waste piles were sprouting and thriving (tomato plants definitely sprouted out of my IRL compost piles from time to time). So given this reality, I think even clay barrels would probably still leave me asking "why can't I just make a dodgy ass compost bin and put some leaves in it!?" Hahaha

At that point, why not just allow the player to create a compost pile without the need for a container? Just place straw into ground storage (or perhaps leaf litter, if that's ever added), then add perishables to it to make it into a compost pile. Could integrate very well with manure mechanics, which I think would be best implemented using straw as well.

 

16 hours ago, v4u6h4n said:

In early agriculture fertiliser, to the extent that it even existed, was likely food and vegetation waste, with the addition of special materials, like manure, nightsoil, ash, bone, etc, coming at least a few thousand years later.

In very early agriculture, maybe. But in the Middle Ages, which is probably of most concern in VS, manure was by far the single most important type of fertilizer. A lot of materials were already known to be beneficial for soil at least in antiquity, though large-scale usage of more specialized types of fertilizer only properly comes into the picture around the 17th century or later for most purposes.

 

On 11/2/2026 at 2:16 PM, Demoncyborg said:

personally, I think the inability to really mess with soil nutrients until you get some kind of metal is just the natural progression of the game and its farming mechanics.

You can buy or find some types of fertilizer before you have metal, and copper is the first major progression milestone in the game so it's an inconvenience more than a meaningful progression gate either way. Any progression after you make a quern and barrel is practically irrelevant to farming.

A bunch of low-demand crops, e.g. turnip or carrot, can be grown even in arctic climates in low fertility soil, no fertilizer and no greenhouse, potentially even with no cold damage if you plant them at the right time. High-demand crops like flax may need medium fertility or some other help, but generally can also be grown in arctic climates with no major issues.

As much as I get the general point, I don't feel like the farming system currently has any meaningful progression at all for most purposes. The only things that really matter is (1) find at least low fertility soil but ideally medium fertility, and (2) find a bunch of seeds - a pretty easy task all things considered, and at that point you're set for life. Higher fertility than medium doesn't matter, because it's expensive and you can just plant more things instead. Even medium isn't particularly important, because in a lot of cases in order to account for yield losses due to cold temperatures when low is insufficient you can also just plant more things instead.

Moving composting to the Stone Age wouldn't really change much, at least in the current balance, and the little progression impact that it might have could instead be offset by the addition of other mechanics.

Edited by MKMoose
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.