The Lerf Posted November 13 Report Posted November 13 In my opinion, the implementation of the beehive kiln has missed the mark a little. While we definitely needed a higher capacity kiln after getting out of the copper/bronze era, the upfront iron and labor cost of the beehive kiln unfortunately relegates it to being a late-game structure. While the ability for the kiln to make all the different flavors of bricks and tiles is great, its main draw should be the larger capacity of items to fire, unlocking at a time when the player is most likely going to be firing a large amount of items (such as the upgrading/construction of their main base, after their access to manufactured items is greatly increased with access to wood boards). This suggestion seeks to remedy the beehive kiln's time of usefulness from late-game cosmetics, to a mid-game workhorse, without removing the unique cosmetic functions. And it's also rather simple, just allow the beehive kiln to function without having iron hatch doors. The Current Implementation - Expensive, Attention-seeking, Out of touch The Proposed Implementation - Sleek, Efficient, Modern We won't be removing the hatches from it's construction completely, just making it so the kiln is functional without them. When the player has the iron needed to make 3 hatch doors, they can be added as usual to give the cosmetic function back to the kiln. And speaking of having the iron needed to make doors, I would reduce the cost of the critical kiln door to remove the iron rods. Five whole ingots is a lot for something we want to be mid-game accessible. For those who aren't aware, the beehive kiln can be constructed with regular old fireclay bricks, the very same that you can construct the bloomery with, which is so much easier than making and using refractory bricks. For those who are aware of that, you also probably know that it's such a ridiculous amount of fireclay needed to make the beehive kiln that even with this proposed change, you wouldn't go through the trouble of firing 142 (!) bricks in pit kilns. That's me. I realized how impractical it is for the beehive kiln to be mid-game after thinking and writing all this up. Like, it's not impossible for a player to build after getting access to iron, but it's asking the player to calcinate ~70 flint, run ~8 pit kilns, and all the associated materials and time and that just seems way too steep to me. The Beehive Kiln will have to be a late-game structure just because of it's size, which is directly responsible for it's material cost. But I really, really don't want all this effort of brainstorming to go to waste. So, now I propose a new structure. The Mini-Beehive Kiln A 2x2x1 intermediary kiln, to drastically reduce the amount of firings needed to produce ceramics in the mid-game. This structure uses around 32 fireclay brick blocks, making it much more similar in commitment to the coke oven (25 fireclay brick blocks). For comparison's sake, the full size beehive kiln uses the equivalent of ~65 fireclay brick blocks in it's construction. This mini-beehive kiln is fired the same way, by filling the space under the grates with a flammable resource. However, there is no door, making it almost feel like a larger bloomery when you have to open it. This feels much more in line with the rest of the mid-game structures based on size and commitment. But more importantly, it fills the role of a higher capacity ceramics kiln that we so desperately need right now. This kiln could be completely filled with fireable items too. For fireclay bricks alone, a full batch would be 96 bricks. Still multiple batches needed to get what's necessary for the full-size beehive kiln, but a much more reasonable number. Hopefully you've read all the way through this in order to follow my train of thought. The beehive kiln is unfortunately too big for it's own good to be anything but a late-game build to get colored ceramics. I still like the idea of having the iron hatches be optional to emphasize its' capacity of production, but this post morphed forms halfway through and i'm not too sure if it's necessary if an intermediate kiln is added. Let me know your thoughts on it 6
Rainbow Fresh Posted November 13 Report Posted November 13 I do very much agree that the beehive kiln is questionably balanced in its core. It is a mighty expensive behemoth that comes too late for its capacity (cause roughly speaking, what would you rather do - fire a few dozen pit kilns to make a cementation furnace or a few dozen pit kilns to make a beehive kiln? And since you hopefully answered cementation furnace, what else will you need the ability to fire 9 stacks at once for after that?) and otherwise just adds a tiny bit of end-game fun for coloring your pottery; but even then I found the base colors to be perfectly sufficient for all my projects. Which is why even in my modded Steel+ age world I have never bothered building one. While simultaneously wishing there was something more advanced than a pit kiln to use because at some point digging a hole, covering it in junk and lighting it on fire just seems too out of touch with the near-industrialized state of advanced machinery covering my base. That said, I do not fully agree with your reasoning. 27 minutes ago, The Lerf said: [...] you wouldn't go through the trouble of firing 142 (!) bricks in pit kilns. [...] but it's asking the player to calcinate ~70 flint, run ~8 pit kilns [...] At (according to the wiki) 12 bricks per pit kiln that would be 12 pit kilns you run simultaneously. To which I say "Of course I'd do and not just because of the lack of an alternative". It's what I've done to build my Tier2 cementation furnace; gather a couple stacks of materials, make the raw Tier 2 refractory bricks then dig a checker pattern field of kilns. Fill them, top them with "worthless, infinitely renewable" resources and light them one by one. Would it have been nicer to just shove them all into one bigger kiln and light it once? Probably. Would that have cost significantly more than a bit of hay, sticks and peat? Absolutely. Using pit kilns isn't the problem. They are the cheapest and easiest option. As mentioned above, the issue is the cost of the bee hive kiln in general on top of its self-obsolescence - something that doesn't stand in good contrast to my personal wish for something more advanced than a hay-filled hole and some colorful pottery. Assuming you have no access to natural fire clay, calcinating all the flint will be the end of you. Not to mention the significantly increased use of fuel. And most importantly, the run-time cost of having your bricks constantly break and needing replacement, as they only have 50% heat resistance. So building the thing once is less an issue than having to constantly re-fire more bricks to repair it using, once more, pit kilns cause the bee hive kiln is broken. Upgrading to refractory bricks is an option for longevity (I assume it is atleast?) but at that point - do you *really* want to invest a cementation furnace worth of stuff into a kiln so you can then invest a second cementation furnace worth in firing it in like 5 times instead of dozens? Or would you rather just do it only once? So I agree that a smaller, cheaper and more reliable alternative just for easier bulk firing would be very nice. The luxury of "colored pottery" can remain an end-game privilege but even as much as a re-usable brick pit kiln that is slightly more fuel efficient would go a long way in reducing tedium and increasing perceived level of progression. 2
jerjerje Posted November 13 Report Posted November 13 2 hours ago, Rainbow Fresh said: Using pit kilns isn't the problem. They are the cheapest and easiest option. As mentioned above, the issue is the cost of the bee hive kiln in general on top of its self-obsolescence - something that doesn't stand in good contrast to my personal wish for something more advanced than a hay-filled hole and some colorful pottery. Assuming you have no access to natural fire clay, calcinating all the flint will be the end of you. Not to mention the significantly increased use of fuel. And most importantly, the run-time cost of having your bricks constantly break and needing replacement, as they only have 50% heat resistance. So building the thing once is less an issue than having to constantly re-fire more bricks to repair it using, once more, pit kilns cause the bee hive kiln is broken. Upgrading to refractory bricks is an option for longevity (I assume it is atleast?) but at that point - do you *really* want to invest a cementation furnace worth of stuff into a kiln so you can then invest a second cementation furnace worth in firing it in like 5 times instead of dozens? Or would you rather just do it only once? The fireclay cost of a beehive kiln is next to nothing compared to its output. Regardless of brick type, they ONLY break when the beehive kiln has been running for 168 (in-game) hours in total. That allows you to use the beehive kiln 15 times, before any bricks have to be replaced. This is a massive amount of clay products, so I doubt most people would ever run into that. If you would only use the beehive kiln for bricks, you could make 9720 bricks costing you only 142 fireclay bricks. And of course only half of the fireclay brick blocks actually get damaged. (And yes, you could use refractory bricks for the beehive kiln too. However this is hardly needed.) As for fuel: While it takes a lot of fuel to fire, this is often much less fuel than you would need for pit kilns. For details on this, here is a table I copied from the wiki. Generally speaking Shingles an Bricks are more fuel efficient in the beehive kiln, but the other clay products tend to take less fuel in a pit kiln. Item type Pit kiln Beehive kiln Maximum items Fuel (any) cost per item Maximum items Firewood cost per item Peat cost per item Coal cost per item Shingle 48 0.083 5184 0.049 0.42 0.01 Brick 12 0.333 648 0.389 0.333 0.083 Quater-block 4 1 72 3.5 3 0.75 Full block 1 4 18 14 12 3 Storage vessel 1 8 27 9.333 8 2 1
jerjerje Posted November 13 Report Posted November 13 3 hours ago, The Lerf said: The Mini-Beehive Kiln I don't think, this quite works as you proposed it. By having the kiln be only one block tall, it will be very fuel inefficient. Keep in mind, that firing a 1-block pit kiln costs 4 firewood/peat. If the mini-beehive kiln is suppose to take the same amount of time as the regular beehive kiln, this will take takes 28 firewood or 24 peat under every grating. This is about six times the fuel consumption! (Or 3 times the fuel, when firing bricks/shingles/tiles, since those can be stacked higher in this kiln). Making the mini kiln 2x2x2 would help this somewhat, but it would still be consuming 3 times the fuel (or 1.5 times for bricks/shingles/tiles) compared to pit kilns. And many clay items cannot be stacked on top of each other. So you could only use the extra height, when making some bricks, shingles or tiles. Additionally, it is questionable whether players need a kiln this large in the mid-game. I feel like I would rarely need that many fired clay items at this stage of the game to be worth the effort of building this kiln. Also if the mini kiln causes bricks to get damaged, too, that would also add another cost to running it.
MKMoose Posted November 13 Report Posted November 13 (edited) To start off, a couple observations about the beehive kiln, which can also be seen in the table shared above by @jerjerje. It has low fuel efficiency for regular, usable ceramic items. Even assuming the kiln is completely full, it uses 3.5x or 3x more firewood or peat than pit kilns respectively, though doesn't use grass and sticks. It can also be fired with coal, but that is a bit difficult to exactly compare - generally, contaminated and brown coal are good, bituminous is fine, while charcoal and coke are not useful. The fact that it is inefficient and even further loses efficiency when not completely full makes it inconvenient to fire regular colored ceramics in small quantities. Its primary use is bricks, tiles and shingles, as it is more efficient than the pit kiln then, and it is extremely useful for some large building projects. The fact that it loses efficiency when not completely full makes it inconvenient until you can accumulate a huge amount of resources to fire - mixing some usable items with some bricks/tiles/shingles is probably the best move for most purposes, but even then it tends to be pretty iffy in the mid-game. I think the core issue with the beehive kiln in some sense is that it naturally produces finished products, which means that you need to prepare exactly the products you need before firing, so a large batch size becomes an inconvenience. Large batch sizes of something like the charcoal pit or the cementation furnace are fine because they process materials which can then be used whenever they are needed, but this does not really apply here. Also, further notes: Realistically, changing the resulting color of ceramics depending on the oxidizing conditons is much more complex than just opening or closing a few hatches, and is to a significant extent possible even in pit kilns. Not to mention, the current colors are arguably the opposite of what they should be realistically. Various minerals present in ceramics and glazes can react very differently to oxidizing or reducing conditions, and these conditions can vary significantly in different locations in the kiln or even across a single ceramic item. Changing the conditions partway through the firing or over multiple firings also influences the end result - the distinct orange-and-black ceramics of Ancient Greece have been made in a process referred to as three-phase firing, for example. While simplifying all of that for the sake of gameplay is perfectly acceptable, it does mean that the implementation ends up pretty arbitrary and can be adjusted with quite a lot of freedom. If we ever get ceramic glazing (which realistically is borderline necessary for ceramics used with food), the overall design space will be expanded and shaken up considerably depending on implementation. Stoneware and especially porcelain may be an interesting additon as well and could change things up somewhat, potentially as a parallel progression step to glazing. 6 hours ago, The Lerf said: The Mini-Beehive Kiln The proposed 2x1x2 intermediate kiln design would have half the fuel efficiency of the beehive kiln for regular ceramics and a third of it for bricks and shingles, assuming it takes the same amount of time to fire. It could potentially be made slightly faster, but not much. So while it's generally a fine idea, I would be wary of two issues: The newfound convenience of the smaller kiln may be largely lost in the fuel costs, and there's actually not much that can be really done to improve it given that the burn time of the fuel is a property of the fuel and not of the kiln. The new kiln could end up kind of boring - just an intermediate design between two extremes, but with no real distinguishing factors of its own. At the same time, due to the beehive kiln currently not being particularly useful aside from aesthetic choices or large building projects, an intermediate design would further take the practical uses away from the beehive kiln. Honestly, I don't know what the optimal solution here might be, mainly because that strongly depends on what exactly the desired direction is. The fact itself that the beehive kiln is used both for color variety and for mass firing of building materials makes things more tricky to design and balance properly, but also makes it less of a one-trick pony. An intermediate design could work fine, but I could also see an argument for a small mid-to-late-game kiln, potentially just one block in size plus fuel below it, to allow convenient firing of small quantities of items with full color selection - this would allow the beehive kiln to lean towards mid-game mass firing. 6 hours ago, The Lerf said: [...] just allow the beehive kiln to function without having iron hatch doors. All that said, I think removing the need for iron hatch doors is probably the most straightforward short-term improvement, ultimately. Perhaps even allow to plug the door with bricks without any need for iron, though ideally it would need a peep hole of some kind to check on the firing progress. The main advantage of this idea is that it makes the beehive kiln into something that can be developed and upgraded with gameplay, which could be more interesting than adding another one-and-done kind of structure. Depending on implementation, it may need adjustments to the ceramic colors, primarily because currently blue clay produces the same black color with two and three open hatches, and red clay produces a pretty uninteresting brown with three open hatches, so the third hatch would be a very low-value improvement, but that's a fairly minor detail. Edited November 13 by MKMoose 1
LadyWYT Posted November 13 Report Posted November 13 I like the beehive kiln, and wouldn't mind an inefficient smaller version that can be obtained earlier in the game. However, the thing your proposal is lacking is that there's no way to control the airflow to produce different colors of pottery, which is one of the primary reasons I build the beehive kiln in the first place. So, I think the main fix would be to make a smaller kiln that allows airflow control, as well as expand on pottery a bit with glazes or some other way to obtain even more colors(the Clayworks mod is a good example). Likewise, perhaps allow traders to buy a wider range of pottery products, so that players can have a market for unwanted pottery, or even let players shatter unwanted pottery and use the shards to make mosaics. 1
MKMoose Posted November 13 Report Posted November 13 3 hours ago, LadyWYT said: I like the beehive kiln, and wouldn't mind an inefficient smaller version that can be obtained earlier in the game. However, the thing your proposal is lacking is that there's no way to control the airflow to produce different colors of pottery, which is one of the primary reasons I build the beehive kiln in the first place. Had similar thoughts behind the suggestion to introduce a small 1-block kiln with full color selection. The beehive kiln's use case could then lean more into mass firing, so it would hopefully retain a distinct and useful place in the game. 3 hours ago, LadyWYT said: Likewise, perhaps allow traders to buy a wider range of pottery products, so that players can have a market for unwanted pottery [...] Would be difficult to make it work properly without a rework to the way that traders currently work. Generally would like to see it, though. 3 hours ago, LadyWYT said: [...] or even let players shatter unwanted pottery and use the shards to make mosaics. Could also be mixed back into raw clay (or directly recycled, for simplicity even if not exactly realistic), used in construction (mortar, concrete, pathways etc.) and used as soil amendment (probably to improve moisture retention). 2 hours ago, LadyWYT said: [...] as well as expand on pottery a bit with glazes or some other way to obtain even more colors(the Clayworks mod is a good example) Personally I think the Clayworks mod is a rather bad example, because while it does provide some nice visual variety, dyes realistically tend to just burn out when fired, at least organic dyes. The distinction which is of interest here (which the vanilla game also doesn't recognize) is between dyes (soluble in liquid, bind at a molecular level, often organic) and pigments (insoluble, need a binder like glue, typically inorganic) - the latter is what you want for ceramics, generally. That aside, I would ask how deep you would want this to go. Even a rather unimpressive number of glaze materials can provide pretty huge color variety. You could have a system with a couple components which can be combined largely freely: Base materials: may influence the opacity, texture and other visual properties of the glaze, usually ground sand/quartz/flint + lead/lime/soda/ash/potash, sometimes with added tin in medieval Europe (to make it more opaque), or based on feldspathic rock in China (for glassy high-temperature glazes). Coloring material: color may be affected by the base materials, and some combinations produce particularly unique patterns like iron variegation, often cobalt (blue), copper (green, turquoise, blue, red), iron (yellow, orange, red, brown, black, green), manganese (purple, brown, black). Firing method: color changes in oxidizing or reducing environments during firing (i.e. will produce different colors depending on the amount of oxygen in the beehive kiln), primarily for glazes with copper or iron, several properties, especially opacity and lustre, may depend on the firing temperature (would need a way to actually adjust that temperature first, though) and potentially a number of other factors. And that's not even mentioning the possibility of potentially hand-painting the glaze or at least a couple patterns, which could offer further customization options beyond what chiseling normally does. I feel like doing this the right way would require a similar overlay system to what wood stains would also benefit from. Then you also have the gameplay-centered question of whether glaze should have any practical effects on durability, food safety or other properties of the ceramics. Making it purely decorative would be fine, but the options are there. 1
The Lerf Posted November 13 Author Report Posted November 13 10 hours ago, jerjerje said: fuel inefficient. So what? There's this concern that things must be straight upgrades over other things, which I don't necessarily get. The benefit of the full-size beehive kiln is colors and capacity, and according to the chart you posted, efficiency over the pit kiln only occurs when fully loading it. Which I don't think most players are doing in their solo games, when the main draw of the beehive kiln is to get colored ceramics. The benefit of this suggested mini-kiln could be capacity and time to bake, or even just aesthetic preference. Do i want to gather grass, sticks, and peat? All very cheap, but could be time consuming to get enough of? Or do I want to just toss in some wood and call it a day? 16 hours ago, Rainbow Fresh said: That said, I do not fully agree with your reasoning. That's fine, the greater part of this suggestion is "A beehive kiln that may actually be used", and not like "a way to invalidate pit kilns". Perhaps the devs intentionally design it so the pit kiln is the cheapest to construct, but takes the longest. The mid-game is supposed to be the point where the player looks more towards ways to decrease the amount of time spent doing labor like that, either through tools, automation, or perhaps an alternate faster way of firing ceramics. If the design or numbers don't work, the design or numbers can be changed. These are just ideas, not a commitment.
Recommended Posts