Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)

With the new update preview I've noticed that the knife and axes got a reasonable buff to how well they work as weapons, with it feeling a lot less clunky. I think adding a toggle to them to disable their function as a tool (much like how you can toggle the new short sword between thrusting and slashing) could make these even more useful in a pinch, just simply letting you press F or whatever your tool mode swap button is and completely disable block selection. When you do accidentally target some grass or dirt, the felling or cutting animation seems to completely block the combat animation from playing, making it feel a bit more clunky if you misclick while fighting a drifter (especially noticeable with the experimental hitboxes enabled).

I'm sure most people aren't going to be using the axes as weapons in the first place, but especially since the ones designed for combat behave the same way this might encourage some people to actually use them as a multi-functional tool. Only downside I could see is bug reports in the future with people wondering why their tool stopped working properly or why they can't target a tree after accidentally swapping the mode.

Edited by MediaevalJames
  • Like 3
Posted
9 minutes ago, MediaevalJames said:

I'm sure most people aren't going to be using the axes as weapons in the first place, but especially since the ones designed for combat behave the same way this might encourage some people to actually use them as a multi-functional tool.

Except I'm fairly certain that the reason we have a felling axe for trees and a couple of other axes for war is...one is meant to be a tool and the others are meant to be weapons. Two very different purposes, and while you can use them in either role, they aren't going to be as effective in a role they aren't designed for.

Personally, I'd rather see the axe weapons be less effective at wood chopping, since as far as I can tell, they have the same bonus to woodcutting as the felling axe. Not to mention that you really shouldn't be using your weapons to do basic chores, since that will break them faster.

Posted (edited)
1 hour ago, LadyWYT said:

Except I'm fairly certain that the reason we have a felling axe for trees and a couple of other axes for war is...one is meant to be a tool and the others are meant to be weapons. Two very different purposes, and while you can use them in either role, they aren't going to be as effective in a role they aren't designed for.

Personally, I'd rather see the axe weapons be less effective at wood chopping, since as far as I can tell, they have the same bonus to woodcutting as the felling axe. Not to mention that you really shouldn't be using your weapons to do basic chores, since that will break them faster.

Not the point I was making, just suggesting adding a toggle to block selection so you can swing them at drifters without accidentally starting their gathering/block breaking animations (both the axe and the knife received new animations, only the flint axes didn't which arguably they should if you consider them more like a tomahawk), I'm not saying they should be the best and most effective weapon especially since I'm also referring to knives. It just feels like a waste to add these animations to the tools (or add tool uses to certain weapons) if using them this way isn't intended in some way, whether as an emergency weapon when going to get your stuff back or simply because it's what you have on hand.

Many cultures have used axes as both tools and weapons (think the Danes/Vikings, Native Americans, and many other ancient civilizations). Beard axes have that shape so you can get your hand under the blade for fine woodworking/whittling. Battle axe being the only one that was intended strictly for combat. I'm sure them all having the same stats is due to it still being a preview and not the final product, but I could see them making the bearded axe a middle of the road option between the three. Otherwise it could just be all of the weapons will be mostly cosmetically different, so players can use the one they like the look of best.

I'm fine with either personally but that's all besides the point of my suggestion of simply making it easier to attack with the current preview axes and knife.

Edited by MediaevalJames
  • Like 3
Posted (edited)

I mean, they could add a toggle by the time the update is finished, just that I don't think it's really needed or necessary. The felling axe is meant for chopping trees so while it can be used in combat, it's not meant to be, hence why there's no "combat mode" to stop the harvest animation if you happen to look at something harvestable. In contrast, the axes meant for combat don't have that issue, since the player is meant to use them to fight and not so much to harvest.

Edit: To put it another way, if axes get a toggle between work and combat modes, they need to first be adjusted so there's a real difference between them. That is, the felling axe should do less damage and have less knockback than the bearded axe or battleaxe, while the bearded axe and battleaxe should retain their damage and knockback values but be slow at chopping. Otherwise what happens is you end up giving the player no reason to carry a dedicated weapon in the early game, since they can just carry a single axe and be done with it(which seems like it may be the case for the current axe balance).

Edited by LadyWYT
  • Like 1
Posted

The basic axe is an effective weapon used throughout history.

Axes designed for battle were lighter, often had a way to hook and pull the opponents equipment and shield, had tapered hafts, and had a larger butt end to make it easier to maintain a grip when pulling.   They also used woods like Ash which are slightly more flexible, shock resistant, and has a long straight grain.  

Howver, some historical battle axes (even some ceremonial ones) do show signs they were used to chop at least some wood.

  • Like 1
Posted (edited)

So based on that, I'd give normal axes a chance to slip out of your hands (maybe 0.5%) [when used in battle] and I'd make battle axes lose 2 durability when used to chop.

Edited by Mac Mcleod
added When Used in Battle
Posted (edited)

Currently the only real drawback I've found to the axe is that the swing speed is slightly slower than the shortsword, and it has slightly less reach. Aside from that though, there doesn't seem to be a good reason to carry a different sidearm than an axe, at least in the early game, since it will provide more utility for less inventory space. Hence why I think it's a little too strong right now, and adding work/combat modes is only going to make that problem worse.

Correction: Swords actually deal more damage than axes. Not sure how I got that turned around. So in that event, they're balanced against other weapons. I continue to stand by my earlier point though, in that I don't think a work/combat mode is really necessary, and the felling axe should be faster at chopping wood but worse at combat.

Edited by LadyWYT
  • Like 1
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.