LadyWYT Posted Thursday at 07:51 PM Report Posted Thursday at 07:51 PM (edited) You can hold left-click to perform repeated attacks, that is all. Some other things: The new monster death animations are very nice, as are the new player attack animations. At a glance, combat feels a lot smoother and more fun, but I expect it's going to require players to relearn how to fight in the game due to the retuned hitboxes and whatnot. There are at least four different types of physical damage: slashing, piercing, tearing, and blunt. Mechanicals are resistant to all physical damage except blunt. However, blunt weapons currently don't feel that much more effective against these creatures; it takes perhaps a hit or two less to kill them, which is a bit underwhelming. The custom armor crafting is interesting, but still very much a WIP to say much here. It's a little confusing to figure out, but it'll be very fun once the devs have polished this feature more. Edited Thursday at 08:35 PM by LadyWYT 4
Teh Pizza Lady Posted Thursday at 09:23 PM Report Posted Thursday at 09:23 PM obviously you're just not using a big enough hammer to combat the mechanicals. Makes me want to whip up a weapon mod right quick. Call it the Percussive Maintainer. It does what you think it does. 1
LadyWYT Posted Thursday at 09:41 PM Author Report Posted Thursday at 09:41 PM 17 minutes ago, Teh Pizza Lady said: obviously you're just not using a big enough hammer to combat the mechanicals. I tested with the flanged mace and warhammer. Not sure if there's something bigger than either of those or not. Interestingly enough, not all maces do blunt damage.
CastIronFabric Posted yesterday at 02:42 AM Report Posted yesterday at 02:42 AM Speaking for myself I just want to still be able to spam hit monsters and move on. That said, I do not mind (maybe even find interesting) the idea of different weapons for different hostiles. I do not venture much into combat as it is so I assume my play style will not be that impacted. I will however make all the armor types because I like makin stuff
LadyWYT Posted 16 hours ago Author Report Posted 16 hours ago (edited) Currently the axe(doesn't matter which one since the stats are the same) seems to be the best early game weapon choice, since it does more damage than the shortsword, can chop wood, and has a lot of knockback. It's actually the sword that has the higher attack value--I misread the tooltip. Axes have a bit more knockback and utility, since they can also serve as a tool. Spears have more reach and can do more damage when thrown, but that also requires you to hit the target in order to do the damage. I mentioned as much elsewhere, but my current impression is that the axes are too similar to each other. The felling axe should have less damage and knockback than its counterparts, but be much more efficient at chopping wood. The bearded axe and battleaxe should retain their current combat stats, but be more inefficient at chopping wood. Can't really say much about the other weapons yet, aside from the slashing attacks seeming to be more effective against multiple enemies. Wolves and bears are still dangerous as always but feel a lot more manageable now thanks to the retuned hitboxes and whatnot. It's still possible for attacks to whiff, but it doesn't happen nearly as often as before, and as long as you're reasonably alert you should be able to react fast enough to put up a fight. The new death animations for creatures also mean that killing hordes of monsters is a lot more entertaining since now they flop over in various ways. Likewise, it's a little easier to tell when you've killed a creature in general since most of the time they immediately flop over dead rather than the previous short delay of standing still for a moment before flopping over. Damage type and attack direction does make a difference on what kind of animation will play, so make sure to vary your attacks to see a wider range of animations. Edited 13 hours ago by LadyWYT 1
MKMoose Posted 13 minutes ago Report Posted 13 minutes ago On 11/19/2026 at 8:51 PM, LadyWYT said: Mechanicals are resistant to all physical damage except blunt. However, blunt weapons currently don't feel that much more effective against these creatures; it takes perhaps a hit or two less to kill them, which is a bit underwhelming. Funny thing is, as you've already seen on GitHub, damage types currently don’t work at all as of pre.1, so any effect that you might have felt was entirely placebo. Design-wise, the damage types are currently underwhelming and largely pointless. There is some implementation which could make them slightly more relevant (and potentially much more restrictive as well in large part due to a some drops potentially being exclusive to specific damage types, which creates more worry than excitement for me), but as of now it is unused. And also, when the damage types start working properly, then every single weapon in the game will be nerfed. Because, for some reason, everything has resistances to all but one damage type per enemy and nothing has any sort of weaknesses. I sincerely hope that it's a temporary thing, because everything in the game is damage spongy quite enough already - it seems very questionable to just reduce all damage by ~20% on average. Granted, some other changes could make up for it slightly, but there's a lot of balancing to be done either way if any of this is supposed to make sense. Do note that all major enemies follow either of two damage multiplier patterns at this time: rotbeasts (drifter, bowtorn, shiver): tearing: 1.0x, slashing attack: 0.9x, piercing attack: 0.75x, blunt attack: 0.5x, mechanicals (locust, bell, and enemies in story locations): tearing: 0.5x, slashing attack: 0.5x, piercing attack: 0.75x, blunt attack: 1.0x. Fish are resistant to blunt attacks, and besides that nothing else currently has any damage multipliers. 16 hours ago, LadyWYT said: Axes have a bit more knockback and utility, since they can also serve as a tool. Spears have more reach and can do more damage when thrown, but that also requires you to hit the target in order to do the damage. I mentioned as much elsewhere, but my current impression is that the axes are too similar to each other. The felling axe should have less damage and knockback than its counterparts, but be much more efficient at chopping wood. The bearded axe and battleaxe should retain their current combat stats, but be more inefficient at chopping wood. My overall thoughts are that different weapons just don't have the "reason to exist" that the devs have been talking about. Even when the damage types start working properly, the different weapons currently just have slightly different numbers, and the fact that there are just two damage multiplier patterns only creates design space for two opposite weapon types (blunt and slashing) and maybe something in-between (piercing). Even with range and knockback factored in, it is difficult to make a properly defensible design argument for any more than ~6 meaningfully unique melee weapon types in the current system, not a whopping 18. And there's at least 6 more weapons mentioned in the game files, mostly or only two-handed - altogether too many for each to be distinct. Vanity is pretty much the only significant dfference between many of them. Regarding the felling axe specifically, I would much prefer if it was an interesting weapon in its own right, not just a tool which can be used as a weak weapon in a pinch. It could deal more damage and have greater knockback with a slower attack speed than a combat axe - not necessarily anything that would make it especially good in combat, but enough to make it distinct in some way and not just worse. Frankly the biggest disappointment of this update, to me, is that while the superficial elements of combat are getting revised, actual core gameplay is pretty much unaffected. The amazing combat strategy of sprinting backwards and smacking helpless animals has not changed absolutely at all and there seems to be no current indication that it might. I honestly don't know if that's "just me", but I simply don't see much of anything good about this combat update - of course it looks nice and all, but you can't always renovate a house with a fresh coat of paint and new furniture alone. The foundational design still has problems, and tacking on new tech or a bunch of weapon variants won't magically fix those underlying issues even if it feels great in the short term.
Recommended Posts