Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted
Just now, Wick said:

Games had to be presented in a proper way and be accepted by the community to be released on Steam.

Steam suffers and will increasingly suffer more from AI slop games. 

I get your AI mod flood for the Mod DB. I really do. I'm also not fond of AI-written descriptions, thumbnails etc., holy shit just show an ingame pic of your implemented shit and write 3-4 sentences, even if its bad. But don't make a 200 line long AI summary for it. One should be able to do so. Even when done mostly by AI, this shows at least you know what you prompted.

Posted (edited)
2 hours ago, Danko Sedin said:

I said top 100.  We are not in "top-10" world yet.

ok, so I stand by what I said and I am not sure why you think that 'Data says a little bit different story' as a recap here is what I said is provided below. The logic problem is, if I am wrong then AI is good because its popular. So which is it? I am completely comfortable saying the most popular mods are not made by AI. would you like me to share with you the list explicitly?

In other words people are either downloading AI mods, telling their friends how awesome those mods are and then other people are downloading them and then they rise to the top of the list even thought they are terrible? that is a contradiction that needs to be explained.

EDIT again: Lets put this all to the test. Tell me the 7 mods in question and we will write down exactly how many downloads they have and then compare that to the top 10 ones. Just to see how wide of a gap it is. Fair?

I think there is some overcomplication happening here on two fronts.

1. the vast majority of the popular mods (if not all of the popular mods) are not using AI. One almost has to intentionally go out of ones way to find AI assisted mods I would think.

2. A mod is either good or or its not, regardless of how its created. As such if its AI slop and bad, it will be bad and because its bad is why one would not use it and it would not rank as the most popular mod in the first place. So the problem, given circular logic, kind of fixes itself.

Edited by CastIronFabric
Posted
1 minute ago, CastIronFabric said:

The logic problem is, if I am wrong then AI is good because its popular. So which is it?

I would assume the problem is volume.

Because of the sheer amount of AI mods, some ends up there.

It's a purely statistical phenomenon.

If I throw a handful of sand at a cup. I would have a higher probability of landing one in the cup than if I was to throw a singular grain. (not sure that was necessary)

The volume is the real problem.

Posted (edited)
7 minutes ago, Wondiws98 said:

I would assume the problem is volume.

Because of the sheer amount of AI mods, some ends up there.

It's a purely statistical phenomenon.

If I throw a handful of sand at a cup. I would have a higher probability of landing one in the cup than if I was to throw a singular grain. (not sure that was necessary)

The volume is the real problem.

actually there is a reason although Steam has thousands of games the most popular ones are actually fair good. This is not some mysterious equation that is some how debated, its rather well known and accepted. In a crowd sourcing approach good content rises to the top. People download it, they talk about it and other people download it and they talk about it. Now if you inject a 3rd party advertiser or fake articles etc that is different but left to its own device the most popular mods are going to represent what people actually like..not what they find terrible.

So the idea that the most popular mods on ModDB are actually terrible is a logic contradiction that needs to be addressed.

 

are we actually prepared to make the argument that the most popular Mods for Vintage Story are actually universally agreed on to be terrible? ok, make that case.

 

I am fairly sure that after about 30 mods on the top list the number of downloads per drops DRAMATICALLY. Most people do not have more than maybe 10-30 mods I would assume. We should actually put my claim to the test and look at the download numbers specfiically. 

Edited by CastIronFabric
Posted
2 minutes ago, CastIronFabric said:

So the idea that the most popular mods on ModDB are actually terrible is a logic contradiction that needs to be addressed.

How did you get to that conclusion? I'm genuinely curious.

Posted (edited)
5 minutes ago, Wondiws98 said:

How did you get to that conclusion? I'm genuinely curious.

actually I did a quick look, I picked a random mod around 50 on the list and I was surprised actually. Its 1/4 the number of downloads as the top of the list. That is not as wide as I had assumed.

Regardless, the point I was making is that if AI mods are bad they will not be high on the list and not download much. Why would they?

just like Steam, there is 147,520 games on Steam. Is just strictly by chance and random roll that 7 Days to Die or The Forest just shows up on the top of the list? just strickly by chance?

no.

Is it hard to find games like 7 Days to Die? no

does one have to actually work hard to hunt for crappy games on Steam? Yes

 

 

 

Edited by CastIronFabric
Posted
3 hours ago, Wick said:

Something that always bothered me is that e.g. Steam removed the Greenlight feature. I don't know whether you know about that as it is almost 10 years "dead" now. But basically it was a community poll for publishing games on the plattform. Games had to be presented in a proper way and be accepted by the community to be released on Steam.

I could imagine such a "check and balances" way for the VS Mod DB. You post a mod and the community can decide (e.g. 7 days) whether the mod is to be listed or not.

This isn't a feature I would ever want to see on the VS database, since it's the kind of thing that all too easily leads to mob rule. And given that parts of the VS community can get incredibly vicious at times, I don't think that's a door that should ever be opened. 

  • Like 1
Posted
49 minutes ago, LadyWYT said:

This isn't a feature I would ever want to see on the VS database, since it's the kind of thing that all too easily leads to mob rule. And given that parts of the VS community can get incredibly vicious at times, I don't think that's a door that should ever be opened. 

As much as personally I would like a ban on AI mods I think the best thing is a filter for people to find mods that aren't made with AI if they wish. I agree that a greenlight system like that just wouldn't work well. For a game store that might work, but for a community project like VS mods that doesn't sound like a good idea.

Posted

The declaration is the part I disagree with, and not because I think AI art is good.

You don't declare if you used Visual Studio or VS Code to write in C#. You don't declare if you used Eclipse or NetBeans or whatever for Java. You don't declare if you used GIMP over Photoshop to create a thumbnail. Fair enough, someone will say generating an asset is not the same as editing one, and I would grant that. It still does not make the declaration a measurement.

Look at the numbers in the original post. 5.9 percent of mods declare AI. His corrected estimate for mods created this year with a public repository is around 42 percent, and the traces he can detect catch fewer than half of the mods that openly declare. So a declaration tells you who bothered to write a sentence, not who used a tool. He also found that authors who declare anything, including "no AI", update more of their mods than the ones who stay silent, which means the tag is tracking how active an author is. That is the opposite of a quality signal.

And a rule you cannot verify only binds the honest. The author who declares gets read through the declaration. The author who strips the agent files and keeps the commit history clean gets read as a purist. That is not a standard, it is a handicap for people who follow it.

So the top of the list may well have undeclared AI in it. That is not a conspiracy theory, it is what his own detection rates imply. Which is why I would judge a mod by the mod. Tag it if the tag is useful for filtering, but stop treating the tag as a verdict, because it is currently a measure of candor.

The tool doesn't decide if driving a nail into a board is the correct action. It only decides how quickly that nail gets driven.

  • Like 1
Posted
6 hours ago, Wondiws98 said:

The Vintage Story Mod DB was a place where people could showcase human passion, talent, creativity and ingenuity

This is your romanization of ModDB. 

Banner says:

Quote

Welcome to the Official Hub for Vintage Story Mods!

It's goal is to simplify access and management of community made modifications to the base game. 

It's all about distribution. 

 

Posted
6 hours ago, VANTABlack2000 said:

At least to me the difference between AI and The Printing Press is that while The Printing Press allows you to make things faster by printing them making it cheaper to produce.

And AI does exactly the same. It makes it cheaper to produce. And you lose something in process. For printing press we lost a craft of handwritten text and custom made covers. BUt gain a literacy. For e-books we lost a paper smell and touch, but gain an library in your pocket. 

6 hours ago, VANTABlack2000 said:

Which is why at least personally I don't like the idea of ANY part of a mod using AI because I see Art in everything down to the code itself

If code is art - should we ban all who doesn't publish it? 

Posted
12 minutes ago, Danko Sedin said:

And AI does exactly the same. It makes it cheaper to produce. And you lose something in process. For printing press we lost a craft of handwritten text and custom made covers. BUt gain a literacy. For e-books we lost a paper smell and touch, but gain an library in your pocket. 

If code is art - should we ban all who doesn't publish it? 

I think you are missing the point in multiple regards.

1. Even with the printing press you can still hand write things and then print it to make it multiple times. With AI using the EXACT SAME prompt doesn't result in the exact same output. It's all a randomization machine that is fooling people with smoke and mirrors. The printing press also doesn't rely on stealing the works of people to do literally anything unlike AI. Because of the requirement to write something before you print it too it doesn't degrade skills or prevent learning like AI does.

2. Not all art needs to be published. Just because I see code as a creative work doesn't mean it should be banned to not publish it. IMO Most people who make art has unpublished work, so I don't know where that statement even comes from. I am merely saying that AI removes an artistic aspect from a mod even if it is used for coding. It also REMOVES learning opportunities because it is just loaning off your intelligence to a machine (That as I mentioned above is also just smoke and mirrors and isn't really intelligent at all) you are better off trying to either learn coding or find someone to help with the coding.

Posted
10 hours ago, Wondiws98 said:

[...] talking politics isn't allowed here.

What makes you say so? Politics certainly aren't welcomed with enthusiasm in most communities and they would typically be directed to off-topic or generally discouraged, but in this case it's definitely relevant to the topic and not to my knowledge in any way prohibited.

 

4 hours ago, LadyWYT said:

This isn't a feature I would ever want to see on the VS database, since it's the kind of thing that all too easily leads to mob rule. And given that parts of the VS community can get incredibly vicious at times, I don't think that's a door that should ever be opened.

I find that outright not allowing a mod to be released without community endorsement is an issue not because of mob rule, but because it may make it difficult for new authors and niche utility mods to get approved without having to ask people to help out, which can be a significant barrier to entry.

One thing that I've never understood, though, is why the Mod DB doesn't have some kind of a like/dislike, rating or review feature. Potentially community tags as well. Can they be exploited in some capacity? Sure... but nearly every single distribution site of any kind provides some way to rate whatever it's distributing, as that is a useful way for the community to self-moderate and inform others of the quality of the content and any of a number of issues. The Mod DB currently has some methods for this, but they are very limited and not dedicated strictly to review or tagging which makes them much less useful in practice.

Posted
3 hours ago, VANTABlack2000 said:

I think you are missing the point in multiple regards.

1. Even with the printing press you can still hand write things and then print it to make it multiple times. With AI using the EXACT SAME prompt doesn't result in the exact same output. It's all a randomization machine that is fooling people with smoke and mirrors. The printing press also doesn't rely on stealing the works of people to do literally anything unlike AI. Because of the requirement to write something before you print it too it doesn't degrade skills or prevent learning like AI does.

Do I? Printing with printing press something handwritten is very expensive. And this is why people moves from fixed stamps to a variable ones. And you will not get the same quality of each page for free either - there is a lot of variables in printing, it is a complicated work. With AI variability of output is just a quirk that you need to take care of if you are looking for consistency of result. Is it complicated? Kinda. Is it impossible? No. 

Claim about stealing is an very aggravated to the degree where it misleads from what is actually happened. AI doesn't steal anything from authors. Stealing and plagiarism were a things before AI. And when they are done now by people with AI assistance - it still as disgusting as done by people without it. 

Let me show you some example.

Did you find below image beautiful?

 Mandel_zoom_07_satellite.jpg.96d48f9202c97104282b277db53adce2.jpg

If so, would you say that I "stole it" If I tell you that it is enough to know something like "z^2 + C" to be able to recreate it, and a dozen of other not less beautiful images?

I don't think so. 

AI doesn't literally steal code or art from somebody. You can't find anything "stolen" in their pocket. 

The real issue is that to create something like "z^2+C" to produce code you need to have a lot of examples of code. And here comes real questions - how to honor authors of that code? How to check that their licenses wasn't broken by such use etc. It is more complicated then stealing.

Posted
3 hours ago, VANTABlack2000 said:

2. Not all art needs to be published. Just because I see code as a creative work doesn't mean it should be banned to not publish it. IMO Most people who make art has unpublished work, so I don't know where that statement even comes from. I am merely saying that AI removes an artistic aspect from a mod even if it is used for coding. It also REMOVES learning opportunities because it is just loaning off your intelligence to a machine (That as I mentioned above is also just smoke and mirrors and isn't really intelligent at all) you are better off trying to either learn coding or find someone to help with the coding.

As a professional programmer I found it very annoying when people talk about code as art, learn by yourself, but can't learn git and GitHub. It is irresponsible in regards for community to do such things, and we tolerate it as nothing. Also, you trust that mod code doesn't do nothing malicious to you in case of closed sources mods is kinda brave. Code need to be published. Even if its art.  

Posted
9 hours ago, CastIronFabric said:

Lets put this all to the test. Tell me the 7 mods in question and we will write down exactly how many downloads they have and then compare that to the top 10 ones. Just to see how wide of a gap it is. Fair?

I don't know how much trust you have to me, I am just a stranger in internet -  do you own research. If you need an example of something in top 100 - take a look into Forgotten Armory. Author give a good description for what exactly AI used in his mod. 

However, I see that you mix thing a little and confuse everyone in thread. 

When people say "AI mods are bad" they could mean two very different things.

One is about ethic of use it. Something like "killing animals is bad". Argument can vary a lot - from "not at all" to "only if it is for looking into VS source code". Because its ethic - you can't argue other side quickly by any rational or emotional argument. For change in ethic - context is something that needs changes first. 

Another is about quality of such mods. Something like - "if it made with AI  - it's sheet". This argument is subjective - people do like different things, and while it would be obvious for you that some mod is sheet - other people could find some fun in using it. Also, it is hard to measure. 

This is why I was looking into something that could be measured - support of mod over time. And I found out that if you are looking for something that wouldn't be abandoned in the middle of journey - label "made with AI" is almost the goods as label "made without AI". And much more powerful label - is a GitHub repository and couple of other mod in author portfolio that survived at least one game release. That it. 

Also, I find out that if you want to keep your mod folder clean with only "hand-written" mods  - you do need to heavily rely on "no ai" statement, because there are some that use AI and don'ts state it, and adoption is growing. 

 

Posted (edited)
1 hour ago, Danko Sedin said:

I don't know how much trust you have to me, I am just a stranger in internet -  do you own research. If you need an example of something in top 100 - take a look into Forgotten Armory. Author give a good description for what exactly AI used in his mod. 

However, I see that you mix thing a little and confuse everyone in thread. 

When people say "AI mods are bad" they could mean two very different things.

One is about ethic of use it. Something like "killing animals is bad". Argument can vary a lot - from "not at all" to "only if it is for looking into VS source code". Because its ethic - you can't argue other side quickly by any rational or emotional argument. For change in ethic - context is something that needs changes first. 

Another is about quality of such mods. Something like - "if it made with AI  - it's sheet". This argument is subjective - people do like different things, and while it would be obvious for you that some mod is sheet - other people could find some fun in using it. Also, it is hard to measure. 

This is why I was looking into something that could be measured - support of mod over time. And I found out that if you are looking for something that wouldn't be abandoned in the middle of journey - label "made with AI" is almost the goods as label "made without AI". And much more powerful label - is a GitHub repository and couple of other mod in author portfolio that survived at least one game release. That it. 

Also, I find out that if you want to keep your mod folder clean with only "hand-written" mods  - you do need to heavily rely on "no ai" statement, because there are some that use AI and don'ts state it, and adoption is growing. 

 

Just give me a name of about 5 of AI mods you are talking about and lets take a look directly.

All the mods I use are in the top mod page and they have been the top mods for longer that the the term 'AI Mods' have been around 'mainstreamed'. 

I am willing to be wrong, so lets take a direct look at the mods you are refering to because I do not see them so I struggle to see how they are taking over the modDB to a problem as described. I literally have to put in work to find AI Mods, they are not showing up in sections I use which is 'most downloaded'.

The only way I personally am going to run into an AI mod is if a lot of people are using said mod, otherwise it will not show up on the page I am using because I do not go that far down the list. So why are a lot of people using AI mods? I do not know, I assume they use them because they are good OR...they actually are not using them in mass.

 

So what are the name of the mods I will look them up myself. Because I will not find them without explicitly looking for them.

 

Edited by CastIronFabric
Posted (edited)
10 hours ago, Wondiws98 said:

blink.thumb.png.0adf5485293809bad6be3152362366a6.png

Do you think its just by chance that the top selling games on Steam have positive reviews? purely by chance?

Or do you think that maybe well reviewed games tend to float to the top of the list of most popular? I mean maaybbeee? maybe I am on to something there?

I mean just hear me out a second. Do you think its possible, just maybe, that top 10 list of games contain games that are fairly good while the super bad ones fall to the bottom? do you think that is possible? If so, them yes. one has to be actively engaged in looking for bad games because those bad games are not going to show up on your front page. This seems reasonable and logical to me I do not understand why this is so novel 

So the only mods I personally ever use or even see when I am looking for mods are mods that a lot of people use. I do not go far down the list of 'most downloaded mods' because there is so many mods on the top of that list it keeps me very occupied. The reason those mods are top of the list is because well they are 'most downloaded' so the question is: Why would terrible mods ever be 'most downloaded'?

Edited by CastIronFabric
Posted
3 minutes ago, Teh Pizza Lady said:

AI bots. Clearly. AI is the bad guy here, remember? Don't lose the plot!

/joke

so you are saying AI bots are downloading tons of AI mods and if I open the mod page right now and search on 'most downloaded' I will easily find AI mods.

 

Give me a name of some of these mods that are supposed to be showing up on my search but are not.

Posted
33 minutes ago, CastIronFabric said:

Just give me a name of about 5 of AI mods you are talking about and lets take a look directly.

Just to make your struggle easier - lets take a look into top-20 mods from Mod DB sorted by most downloads. 

Check Carry On, Alchemy and Pet AI please.

Posted (edited)
3 minutes ago, Danko Sedin said:

Just to make your struggle easier - lets take a look into top-20 mods from Mod DB sorted by most downloads. 

Check Carry On, Alchemy and Pet AI please.

Carry On, Alchemy have been around far longer that 'AI mods'. You are saying those are AI mods? 

let me check

 

Nope.. The text 'AI ' does not exist anywhere in the description for Carry On mod.

What is the point of this exercise exactly?

Edited by CastIronFabric
Posted
2 hours ago, Danko Sedin said:

And I found out that if you are looking for something that wouldn't be abandoned in the middle of journey - label "made with AI" is almost the goods as label "made without AI". And much more powerful label - is a GitHub repository and couple of other mod in author portfolio that survived at least one game release. That it.

That is the finding, and it is sitting in a reply to someone who is not going to read it. It also predicts something testable about the database rather than about AI: a mod with a public repo and an author who has already survived a release is the better bet, label or no label. If that still holds at 1.23, then the thing worth putting on a mod page is the repo link, not the AI tag. That is a suggestion the moderators can act on without settling the ethics question at all.

On 11/11/2026 at 3:31 AM, Danko Sedin said:

The conclusion about AI rests on one game release (1.22) and 45 mods from 36 authors; "updated" is not "alive". The point will be made by a pre-registered check on 1.23: the method will be published before the data exists.

This is the most unusual thing in the thread and it went past everyone. You have written down what you will check and how, before the data exists, which makes your claim the only one in here that can lose. So ask the people who are certain for their number now. What share of the AI mods that face 1.23 will still be updated six months after it, and what result would make them say the vibe was wrong. Anyone who writes a number gets taken seriously in January. Anyone who does not has told you it is a preference, which is allowed, but a preference is something they need to handle on their own end instead of requiring you or someone else to cater to them, IMO.

2 hours ago, Danko Sedin said:

When people say "AI mods are bad" they could mean two very different things.

One is about ethic of use it. Something like "killing animals is bad". Argument can vary a lot - from "not at all" to "only if it is for looking into VS source code". Because its ethic - you can't argue other side quickly by any rational or emotional argument. For change in ethic - context is something that needs changes first.

Nobody has disagreed with your update rates except one person, and they are asking for a name list rather than a number. Everyone else is answering the ethics question, which is about what belongs on the database, and that is a decision for the people who run it, which is a stance I've shared before in other threads. No survival curves are great and they're interesting data, but the only thing that matters is what the official people in charge think and they've been loudly quiet about it.

One thing before you go back to the data. You have spent today answering the same three dissenters. Your supporters need some love, too. :) 

From your data it looks like half of the mods posted get dropped at every game release, and always have. That is not a story about AI. That is a story about volunteers not finishing the job. One need look no further than the endless variety of stick mods that have been abandoned with every game update for concrete proof of that statement.

12 minutes ago, CastIronFabric said:

so you are saying AI bots are downloading tons of AI mods and if I open the mod page right now and search on 'most downloaded' I will easily find AI mods.

 

Give me a name of some of these mods that are supposed to be showing up on my search but are not.

That's the joke.

  • Like 1
Posted
3 minutes ago, CastIronFabric said:

Carry On, Alchemy have been around far longer that 'AI mods'. You are saying those are AI mods? 

let me check

 

Nope.. The text 'AI ' does not exist anywhere in the description for Carry On mod.

What is the point of this exercise exactly?

I am saying that AI has been used in their development. Are you following our discussion or just fool around?

Have you take a look into repo of CarryOn?

×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.