Having read through this thread, I find myself in full agreement with this effort poster, Nicodemus. The old logo has never looked appealing as a desktop icon, nor would the new one Tyron has presented to us. An entirely new logo akin to Nicodemus' should be created, incorporating design elements from the original for the sake of legacy, of course, whilst being beautiful in both large and small forms. Nobody wants low-detail, minimalist nonsense, and a video game logo must be aesthetically pleasing as both an icon and a splash screen.
However, if forced to choose between the old logo and the new, I would choose the old one purely for its soul and its history as an established symbol of Vintage Story.