Jump to content

Would a thirst mechanic be fitting for Vintage Story? and how should it be implemented?


Recommended Posts

Posted

Personally I'd rather not have a thirst mechanic, I feel that there's enough things to juggle as is. The best implementation would probably be to add water values to food, and just let you drink boiled water to avoid taking damage from dirty water, it'd fall squarely into progression via the jug and make it more valuable as an item to have.

Though making it not just another hunger bar would be the hardest part, perhaps it could be primarily an issue in hotter regions, where your hydration would go down faster, heatstroke and dehydration etc. A new bar that isn't just "food is your fuel and you use it up by moving around and healing". I think adding it would be difficult to balance around how many things the player already has to juggle and worry about, and it might go the way of Project Zomboid in making the game too much of a chore.

Posted (edited)
1 hour ago, Rezerkity said:

Personally I'd rather not have a thirst mechanic, I feel that there's enough things to juggle as is. The best implementation would probably be to add water values to food, and just let you drink boiled water to avoid taking damage from dirty water, it'd fall squarely into progression via the jug and make it more valuable as an item to have.

Though making it not just another hunger bar would be the hardest part, perhaps it could be primarily an issue in hotter regions, where your hydration would go down faster, heatstroke and dehydration etc. A new bar that isn't just "food is your fuel and you use it up by moving around and healing". I think adding it would be difficult to balance around how many things the player already has to juggle and worry about, and it might go the way of Project Zomboid in making the game too much of a chore.

I hear you on so much to juggle. I personally would balance it by removing surface drifters and rifts and add hydration instead.

Effectively that is exactly what I do via the settings 

Edited by CastIronFabric
  • Like 1
  • 2 weeks later...
Posted (edited)

I think it would be an interesting implementation into the game, but honestly more like at higher difficulties more than anything and perhaps just different levels of drainage between the difficulties in-game. Because what often happens when you start adding something like that, it then just starts to become a hassle. Who knows though and maybe they'd go about it much differently whenever the idea is approached on their end. 

Edited by Originalblue
Posted (edited)

There are many ways one COULD implement thirst. These are two approaches that I like. 

One is a very lightweight (gameplay wise) approach, which is to just make drinking water a buff to your temperature resistance to heat. So, drinking water cools you down for a few hours or so. Not needed most of the time, but during summers or in hot environments, you might need it. It adds a unique challenge to hot environments without being too overbearing elsewhere. 

Two, I actually quite like project zomboids approach to water, which is that if you have a container that is holding water, you drink from it automatically when you're thirsty. So it's almost like a shield against the effects of dehydration. It sounds like it's still just another "bar that has to be managed", and it kind of is, but its less of a pain than you would think, as auto-consuming the water lets you mentally away needing to drink water now, so you can better focus on getting water later. Maybe just add an idle animation of your character drinking from a bottle if you arent holding a sword or doing something else to indicate that you do still have water in your container. 

Now, SHOULD it be implemented? I mean... the game does advertise itself as "uncompromising wilderness survival", and when i hear that i think of like, green hell, which does have thirst. I find normal food to be kind of annoying (limited freedom in cooking, frequent needing to eat), so i wouldnt complain if they decided against it.

That being said, if they want to stick to the original vision i would think they would add it, but i agree with 

On 9/18/2026 at 10:41 AM, LadyWYT said:

I think if a thirst mechanic were added though, it'd need to be after status effects are added, so that there's a penalty for drinking dirty water. Additionally, world generation would probably need a rework, since there's water everywhere and thus no need to really worry that much about hydration

this, +an "alchemy" system, so water can be a more important resource than just for your drinking (and so alcohol/aqua vitae is useful for something), and +rivers. So basically, not yet, if ever. 

Sometimes a game changes beyond its original vision, and they have seem to have been walking away from the "uncompromising wilderness survival" in favor for more homesteading and crafting stuff, so needing water might not fit in the future.

Edited by Chuckerton
Posted
On 9/24/2026 at 3:53 AM, Banch said:

. I haven't used the well-digging mechanics because surface water is everywhere, which is kind of a shame since being able to make wells that actually work seems like a fun addition to the game.

Clean well water has no hunger penalty unlike unboiled surface water.

Posted (edited)

To reiterate my opinion I think having thirst mechanics in a game like this is obvious and does not need to be overcomplicated. I think this might be the only building/survial game I have ever played that does not have thirst mechanics in it. I am not exactly sure what parameters makes up a 'survival' game such that the use of the word has an actual meaning or not but I would think 'thirst mechanics' would be on that list as well.

Now as far as overloading the players during early and mid game I agree, this game has a huge list of things to manage and take care of and adding thirst mechanics would add to that list of things to manage, kind of like.....combat overhaul would. So in my personal opinion I would rather see thirst over combat weapon management. I do understand that part is an opinion not something I am saying as a fact. Regardless however, I think some people are way over complicating the 'no' to the quesiton of having thirst mechanics in this game.

Edited by CastIronFabric
Posted

Not to insult anybody, but I feel like the people who oppose thirst on the grounds of "it will just be another bar to manage" are lacking in imagination.

Take the current hunger mechanic. It really is just managing 5 bars. Honestly even calling  that "management" is an act of charity: you only have to worry about keeping as many of them full: there aren't any decisions involved in that. Now, the lack of imagination I refer to is assuming that the the only thirst mechanic possible is just adding another bar to keep full.

That assumption is of course a bit of an  insult to the art of game design.

Now, onto metric for how good a gameplay system is. My favourite one, as one may guess, is the number of decisions it opens up to the player. The current hunger mechanic is C tier by that metric, meaning: it at least doesn't take decisions away from other areas of the game, but it certainly doesn't add much.

Now, how could adding thirst make food more decision-heavy, without any changes to the hunger system itself?

Here's one minimally annoying version:

Thirst bar depletion only slightly affects movement speed, meaning you don't need to care about thirst while doing chores at your base.

Foods gain a thirst depletion stat that is balanced against how long lasting the food is. For example, salted and dried foods are easy to keep, and you can fit a lot of them into just one inventory slot. As a downside, they will negatively affect your thirst. Now you have decisions involved with picking your foods depending on activity. Do you bring a crock with you for a faster travel, but risk running out, or do you stuff your pocket full of jerky and potentially sacrifice some time in case you don't come across any water?

Posted (edited)

No. No one wants to play food and drink simulator. You want to stop mining, building or exploring every 5 minutes to eat AND drink?

 

Additionally, players already die constantly in the early game, either by starving or wilds animals. This just sounds like another way to make the game even more tedious. People wonder why this game isn't more popular. The average gamer doesn't like tedious. 

Edited by KahvozeinsFang
Posted
14 minutes ago, KahvozeinsFang said:

The average gamer doesn't like tedious. 

This game doesn't target the average gamer, it targets the gamer who is into this kind of game, otherwise it'd be a cinematic first person shooter or a sports game.

Posted
4 hours ago, hjvtdev said:

Not to insult anybody, but I feel like the people who oppose thirst on the grounds of "it will just be another bar to manage" are lacking in imagination.

Take the current hunger mechanic. It really is just managing 5 bars. Honestly even calling  that "management" is an act of charity: you only have to worry about keeping as many of them full: there aren't any decisions involved in that. Now, the lack of imagination I refer to is assuming that the the only thirst mechanic possible is just adding another bar to keep full.

That assumption is of course a bit of an  insult to the art of game design.

Now, onto metric for how good a gameplay system is. My favourite one, as one may guess, is the number of decisions it opens up to the player. The current hunger mechanic is C tier by that metric, meaning: it at least doesn't take decisions away from other areas of the game, but it certainly doesn't add much.

Now, how could adding thirst make food more decision-heavy, without any changes to the hunger system itself?

Here's one minimally annoying version:

Thirst bar depletion only slightly affects movement speed, meaning you don't need to care about thirst while doing chores at your base.

Foods gain a thirst depletion stat that is balanced against how long lasting the food is. For example, salted and dried foods are easy to keep, and you can fit a lot of them into just one inventory slot. As a downside, they will negatively affect your thirst. Now you have decisions involved with picking your foods depending on activity. Do you bring a crock with you for a faster travel, but risk running out, or do you stuff your pocket full of jerky and potentially sacrifice some time in case you don't come across any water?

nearly every single 'survial'/'building' game I am aware of has a thirst bar and I would struggle to think of one that does not, its extremely common and I fail to understand why people are treating this 'idea' as if its a novel concept.

 

Posted (edited)
59 minutes ago, KahvozeinsFang said:

No. No one wants to play food and drink simulator. You want to stop mining, building or exploring every 5 minutes to eat AND drink?

 

Additionally, players already die constantly in the early game, either by starving or wilds animals. This just sounds like another way to make the game even more tedious. People wonder why this game isn't more popular. The average gamer doesn't like tedious. 

I struggle to know what the definition of a 'survival' game would be if not Call of Duty. The only parameters I can think of are food water and temperature. 

and Food is very much a major foundation of this game, its not in Call of Duty though to be fair

Edited by CastIronFabric
Posted
1 hour ago, hjvtdev said:

This game doesn't target the average gamer, it targets the gamer who is into this kind of game, otherwise it'd be a cinematic first person shooter or a sports game.

I heard somewhere they have sold a million copies of this game. Not sure if it's true, but I guess it could be possible. The problem is, LOTS of people have played this game, but not many stick around. It really doesn't take a genius to figure out why. I've seen it first hand. 

 

I bought this game for my niece and she loved it... for one day. When I asked her why she didn't want to play anymore she said she didn't like all the little things she has to do to get anything done. And this coming from a 13 year old who plays 7 Days to Die on insane nightmare. So difficulty wasn't the problem. 

 

This is a sandbox survival game. It targets a fairly large audience. If you think survival games don't, you're lying to yourself. 

Posted
1 hour ago, CastIronFabric said:

nearly every single 'survial'/'building' game I am aware of has a thirst bar and I would struggle to think of one that does not

I can think of one extremely popular game that doesn't. But everyone else here is too scared to call it by it's name. I'll give you one guess. 

Posted (edited)
2 hours ago, KahvozeinsFang said:

I can think of one extremely popular game that doesn't. But everyone else here is too scared to call it by it's name. I'll give you one guess. 

I have never played Minecraft but I assume that is what you are referring to. You think this game and its very Novel approach to not having hydration unlike most games of its type is because its tightly coupled to Minecraft ideology of no hydration of which itself is likely not rooted in anything specific other than just never getting around to it? I thought this game was supposed to be an upgrade to Minecraft, not a subservient to all things Minecraft 

Regardless, it appears the answer to 'why are some against hydration in VS unlike the vast majority of survival games?' the answer is 'because Minecraft does not have it. duly noted. 

Edited by CastIronFabric
Posted
35 minutes ago, CastIronFabric said:

Regardless, it appears the answer to 'why are some against hydration in VS unlike the vast majority of survival games?' the answer is 'because Minecraft does not have it. duly noted. 

The interesting part here is that the Minecraft mod VS is ostensibly inspired by did have thirst.

Posted (edited)
3 hours ago, CastIronFabric said:

Regardless, it appears the answer to 'why are some against hydration in VS unlike the vast majority of survival games?' the answer is 'because Minecraft does not have it. duly noted. 

I used Minecraft as an example of a game without a thirst mechanic. I said nothing about VS not having thirst "because Minecraft does not have it"

 

I would imagine the reason VS doesn't have a thirst mechanic is because the devs don't feel like coding in something that's not really needed. But I have no idea why there isn't, that's just speculation. Although, I have played this game hundreds and hundreds of hours, and never once did I think it would be greatly improved with thirst. 

 

So you tell me, what is it about thirst that would make this game better? And please have a better answer than "because other games have it".

 

Oh and also, isn't using the hydrate mod good enough? People seem to like those dragon and magic mods, but I don't see anyone asking for those in vanilla. 

Edited by KahvozeinsFang
Posted (edited)

I don't like addition of a thirst mechanic on top of the hunger mechanic, but it could be tied into a system for heat exhaustion to mirror the freezing cold. Then drinking may just be one of the options to cool down. To make it a non trivial option, it must be juice or wine, but there is no carrying capacity penalty. A bucket of water can still be used, but only as a cold shower for the getting wet effect. 

The heat exhaustion should not be too punishing, but the sun has a heating effect and the same for sprinting and hard work.

Being in the sun and doing work or running with some rest breaks in the temperate summer = OK

Just chilling in the tropical summer or doing work with breaks outside of the sun = OK

Being in the sun or working outdoors in a tropical summer = OVERHEATING, get wet or drink on top of breaks. 

The warm start summers will be in between with running in the sun being more punishing than in the temperate, but cooling down easier than in the tropics.

 

So the heat system should be balanced towards tropical summer = restricted activity but not an overall punishment just for being alive, mirroring the temperate winters.

For the hardcore people just pick a hotter option with 50-60C summers = ALWAYS HOT, choose pain = get pain. Choose normal starts = get normal game. 

 

Mining is a problem with this system though. As it stands now the deep underground temperature is relative to the surface temperatures, which is a bit silly. Yes deep mining should be HOT but not much worse in tropical weather compared to temperate weather (including tropical winters). Rebalance is needed.

Edited by MobiusvanMars
considered mining
Posted
On 9/18/2026 at 11:41 AM, LadyWYT said:

Yes, but...what "correctly" looks like is going to vary heavily depending on who you ask.

A thirst mechanic makes sense for a survival game, and lends some unique challenge to hot environments since there's currently not much environmental survival pressure in those areas. However, the main drawback of thirst is that, in essence, it's the same thing as the hunger mechanic, just something that you'll need to take care of more frequently, with bigger repercussions if you don't(Hydrate or Diedrate, anyone?). And I'm not so sure it's a good idea to add yet another meter that the player will need to micromanage into the game. There could be an option to turn it off, of course, but it seems a waste to implement an entire system like that(a system that will likely affect several other gameplay systems) only to allow the player to ignore it entirely.

I think if a thirst mechanic were added though, it'd need to be after status effects are added, so that there's a penalty for drinking dirty water. Additionally, world generation would probably need a rework, since there's water everywhere and thus no need to really worry that much about hydration outside of a couple of story locations where water is practically non-existent. 

If it were to be implemented, the best way I can imagine is to have a canteen system. Your seraph will automatically drink from your canteen (inventory, maybe a new slot?), and you will have to refill it now and then (making sure to disinfect and/or filter). This adds a challenge in environments with very little freshwater, on long-distance voyages and sailing, and doesn't force you to frequently interact.

In my opinion, this system actually sounds pretty fun to have in the game because it challenges the player and fits into the progression system. Your first canteen could be made of hide, the next one metal, then leather, etc. Charcoal filters would clear up dirt, and boiling the water would disinfect it. Anyone who's sunk their teeth into the game should be able to do this in their first couple of days; However, that's the problem. This could be hard early on and very frustrating for first-time players, which is why I suspect this system isn't in the game despite the rigor of Vintage Story's survival mechanics.

Posted (edited)
9 hours ago, KahvozeinsFang said:

I used Minecraft as an example of a game without a thirst mechanic. I said nothing about VS not having thirst "because Minecraft does not have it"

 

I would imagine the reason VS doesn't have a thirst mechanic is because the devs don't feel like coding in something that's not really needed. But I have no idea why there isn't, that's just speculation. Although, I have played this game hundreds and hundreds of hours, and never once did I think it would be greatly improved with thirst. 

 

So you tell me, what is it about thirst that would make this game better? And please have a better answer than "because other games have it".

 

Oh and also, isn't using the hydrate mod good enough? People seem to like those dragon and magic mods, but I don't see anyone asking for those in vanilla. 

let me repeat then so that is clear and does not get missed.

I am not aware of any survial game that does not have thrist mechanics in it, I am not sure how a survial game can be defined as a survial game without thrist mechanics or rather at least hunger mechanics. I am sure there exists a few survial games without thrist mechanics but its extremely common and I fail to understand why people think its a novel idea that should not exist in this survial game.

Now is minecraft a survial game? I do not know

 

Edited by CastIronFabric
Posted (edited)
3 hours ago, an_egg_cultist said:

If it were to be implemented, the best way I can imagine is to have a canteen system. Your seraph will automatically drink from your canteen (inventory, maybe a new slot?), and you will have to refill it now and then (making sure to disinfect and/or filter). This adds a challenge in environments with very little freshwater, on long-distance voyages and sailing, and doesn't force you to frequently interact.

In my opinion, this system actually sounds pretty fun to have in the game because it challenges the player and fits into the progression system. Your first canteen could be made of hide, the next one metal, then leather, etc. Charcoal filters would clear up dirt, and boiling the water would disinfect it. Anyone who's sunk their teeth into the game should be able to do this in their first couple of days; However, that's the problem. This could be hard early on and very frustrating for first-time players, which is why I suspect this system isn't in the game despite the rigor of Vintage Story's survival mechanics.

I do not know why people are acting as if this is an idea that has never been done before and there is so many questions on how we could possibly do it.

Yes, canteens, done.

Maybe I am wrong, maybe my memory is faulty and old but I could  have sworn that many survial games already have hydration mechanics and this is not some kind of mystery. I know Green Hell does, I know Rising World does. Maybe later I will have to research this some more to double check my memory but it just feels like this is extremely common 

Edited by CastIronFabric
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.