DarkGold Posted November 6 Report Posted November 6 Currently, if your temporal stability meter (the cyan gear between your health and hunger bar, as mentioned in the handbook) is less than 100%, it will slowly regenerate over time in temporally stable areas. When the player sleeps, the amount of time they spend asleep does not affect the temporal stability meter. Temporal stability (in the case of stable or unstable regions) seems like something that is less connected to conscious experience than physical space, so for the period of time that you are unconscious your temporal stability should continue to be affected, like hunger will continue to affect you while you are asleep. If the player were to go mining underground in an unstable area, then return to the surface and sleep, it would be convenient to get temporal stability back while sleeping (assuming the bed is in a temporally stable area). This would let the player go back to mining when they awake sooner without being forced to spend a temporal gear to regain temporal stability, or whiling away their time on other activities while waiting for their temporal stability to regenerate. 4
LadyWYT Posted November 6 Report Posted November 6 1 hour ago, DarkGold said: When the player sleeps, the amount of time they spend asleep does not affect the temporal stability meter. Temporal stability (in the case of stable or unstable regions) seems like something that is less connected to conscious experience than physical space, so for the period of time that you are unconscious your temporal stability should continue to be affected, like hunger will continue to affect you while you are asleep. I agree with the premise, but I'll throw a wildcard idea into the mix: stability should slowly increase while the player is sleeping in a neutral or unstable area. That way if a player settles in an unstable area by accident(as happens fairly often with newer players), they'll have a workaround for it instead of needing to go with a more drastic option. Of course, the stability gained by sleeping should only be enough to counteract surface level instability--the higher instability of underground regions and stronger temporal storms is going to be enough to override that stability gain, so the player will still overall lose stability if they choose to sleep in a particularly unstable area. 4
Zaph42nd Posted November 6 Report Posted November 6 2 hours ago, DarkGold said: Temporal stability (in the case of stable or unstable regions) seems like something that is less connected to conscious experience than physical space, so for the period of time that you are unconscious your temporal stability should continue to be affected, like hunger will continue to affect you while you are asleep. For sure, it's give more utility to beds and probably incentivize seeking upgrades to your beds as well.... Currently there's not much reason aside from aesthetics to switch from a hay-bed to a wooden or aged wood bed aside from being able to sleep an extra 90-180 mins. Perhaps better beds would also give slightly more stability, though minimally so 1 hour ago, LadyWYT said: stability should slowly increase while the player is sleeping in a neutral or unstable area. That way if a player settles in an unstable area by accident(as happens fairly often with newer players), they'll have a workaround for it instead of needing to go with a more drastic option Also agree with this, it'd not just benefit new players but also would incentivize building outposts into more dangerous areas and avoiding night-travel, that'd also work well to motivate building roads/canals or other travel networks within the world 2
Mac Mcleod Posted November 6 Report Posted November 6 In most cases the fix for settling in an unstable area is to walk in a 50 block radius and find the area that is stable (it's always been that close) and build a "Stabilitarium" there.
Teh Pizza Lady Posted November 7 Report Posted November 7 The premise is right, but I think the diagnosis points somewhere else. Stability is a property of where you are and what's happening: the local value is derived from position, depth and storm, and nothing about being conscious changes any it. What is off is not the consciousness, it is the clock. Sleeping does not pause your needs, it accelerates the calendar. Stability is the one need that does not care about the calendar. Tiredness has an explicit sleep branch and works off total in game hours. Body temperature checks whether you are asleep and also keys off total hours. Hunger has no sleep branch at all, but it scales its drain by the time speed, which is exactly the number sleeping pushes from 60 to 17000, so you wake up roughly as hungry as those hours would have made you. Only stability is driven by real frame time, in BehaviorTemporalStabilityAffected, with no calendar reference and no sleep check anywhere in that method. That is why the bar barely moves overnight. A slept night is a few seconds of real time, so you get a few ticks of regeneration instead of seven hours of it. It is not that you were unconscious; it is that the other three are counting in game hours and this one is counting in wall clock seconds. There is an open bug report for the topic of this thread, issue 6030 from June, with no reply on it. So I would reframe the suggestion as a consistency fix rather than a new mechanic: a slept night should count as elapsed game time for stability too, at whatever rate the ground under the bed supports. This would make it operate the same way that hunger and other mechanics that are based on in-game time. And also maybe comment on the bug report thread so Anego has more visibility on it since the person who submitted it was playing modded. A GitHub account is free and takes 2 minutes to create and chiming in to say it also happens in vanilla may be the exact clue they're looking for to prioritize a fix. 1
DarkGold Posted November 8 Author Report Posted November 8 15 hours ago, Teh Pizza Lady said: There is an open bug report for the topic of this thread, issue 6030 from June, with no reply on it. So I would reframe the suggestion as a consistency fix rather than a new mechanic: a slept night should count as elapsed game time for stability too, at whatever rate the ground under the bed supports. This would make it operate the same way that hunger and other mechanics that are based on in-game time. And also maybe comment on the bug report thread so Anego has more visibility on it since the person who submitted it was playing modded. A GitHub account is free and takes 2 minutes to create and chiming in to say it also happens in vanilla may be the exact clue they're looking for to prioritize a fix. Ah, thank you for directing me to the issue and suggesting I comment. I have an existing GitHub account, so it took no time at all.
Recommended Posts