Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted (edited)
7 hours ago, Teh Pizza Lady said:

Download count isn't really indicative of good quality..

I don't have a strong data about it, but my small experience with my only mod tells me that in order to grab a lot of downloads you need to do basically two things: 

  • first you need to "sell" your mod to server owners. Convince one guy - you get 30 downloads. 
  • and second -  you need to update often. every update - you farm you servers for downloads. as long as wave become shallow - its time to release new update and farm a little bit more.
Edited by Danko Sedin
Posted (edited)
15 hours ago, ArgentLuna said:

As long as its flagged as being made with AI so that the people who don't wish to use it can avoid it, otherwise its a slippery slope of dictating who can what on a page meant for people who are sharing their alterations to this game (which is itself three mods in a trenchcoat)

One of my favorite games of all time has had a strong negative rating for about a decade on Steam. This is why I do not support the curation model, at least as it would apply to removing something. Steam had a good idea (although its not working well) that of curators. If you trust a youtuber or whomever to curate video games for you, then you can go their store page directly and just buy what they suggest. Its a good idea, but it never caught on.

Regardless, this entire conversation has a foundation assumption that Carry On mod, Alchemy and Better Ruins Mod are actually 1. AI mods and 2. Not actually popular 3. 'Bad' by proxy of being 'AI Slop'

EDIT: I can not really say what I think of that but I can just say, I do not think this conversation has a foundation that is being realistic.

 

Edited by CastIronFabric
Posted
6 hours ago, Danko Sedin said:

I don't have a strong data about it, but my small experience with my only mod tells me that in order to grab a lot of downloads you need to do basically two things: 

  • first you need to "sell" your mod to server owners. Convince one guy - you get 30 downloads. 
  • and second -  you need to update often. every update - you farm you servers for downloads. as long as wave become shallow - its time to release new update and farm a little bit more.

I think it's a little more than that. Yes, server owners installing your mod helps, since that means at least a couple extra downloads, if not more(depends on how big the server is). Updates...eh. Yes, they can add to the total download count, but updates alone don't determine whether someone chooses to try the mod or otherwise keep using it. Update numbers are also why it's important to look at the download totals per version of a mod, rather than the total lifetime downloads, since that paints a clearer picture of how many people are actually using the mod on average.

The main factor behind what makes a mod popular is what content the mod includes and the quality of said content. A mod that adds content that a lot of people want to play with, and that is well-made, will generally gain quite a lot of traction, though it can take some time. A mod that adds content that not many want or that has poorly made content, however, tends to fall to the wayside. That's also why the number of follows don't necessarily mean a lot either; yes, having a lot of follows is generally a good thing, but if there's not a high download count to go with it, it tends to indicate that people are interested in watching potential development but not really interested in actually playing with the mod.

Posted
1 hour ago, LadyWYT said:

I think it's a little more than that. Yes, server owners installing your mod helps, since that means at least a couple extra downloads, if not more(depends on how big the server is). Updates...eh. Yes, they can add to the total download count, but updates alone don't determine whether someone chooses to try the mod or otherwise keep using it. Update numbers are also why it's important to look at the download totals per version of a mod, rather than the total lifetime downloads, since that paints a clearer picture of how many people are actually using the mod on average.

The main factor behind what makes a mod popular is what content the mod includes and the quality of said content. A mod that adds content that a lot of people want to play with, and that is well-made, will generally gain quite a lot of traction, though it can take some time. A mod that adds content that not many want or that has poorly made content, however, tends to fall to the wayside. That's also why the number of follows don't necessarily mean a lot either; yes, having a lot of follows is generally a good thing, but if there's not a high download count to go with it, it tends to indicate that people are interested in watching potential development but not really interested in actually playing with the mod.

made harder by the fact that in order to keep the mod updated (and having the motivation to keep at it), having feedback is important. when no one bothers to give feedback, problems that could have been fixed earlier gets unresolved and as is often the case is discovered too late.

  • Like 1
Posted
2 hours ago, LadyWYT said:

I think it's a little more than that. Yes, server owners installing your mod helps, since that means at least a couple extra downloads, if not more(depends on how big the server is). Updates...eh. Yes, they can add to the total download count, but updates alone don't determine whether someone chooses to try the mod or otherwise keep using it. Update numbers are also why it's important to look at the download totals per version of a mod, rather than the total lifetime downloads, since that paints a clearer picture of how many people are actually using the mod on average.

The main factor behind what makes a mod popular is what content the mod includes and the quality of said content. A mod that adds content that a lot of people want to play with, and that is well-made, will generally gain quite a lot of traction, though it can take some time. A mod that adds content that not many want or that has poorly made content, however, tends to fall to the wayside. That's also why the number of follows don't necessarily mean a lot either; yes, having a lot of follows is generally a good thing, but if there's not a high download count to go with it, it tends to indicate that people are interested in watching potential development but not really interested in actually playing with the mod.

I agree. I look at my per version downloads to gauge where I'm at and to give myself an idea if there is enough interest to continue (although I am excited for 2k total for some reason). I think there is another thing about updates and that's "what kind of update is it?"  Is the creator adding more content to their mod, adding compatibility for other mods, or are they just pumping out one bug fix after another because they didn't test enough before release.  

  • Like 3
Posted
6 hours ago, LadyWYT said:

The main factor behind what makes a mod popular is what content the mod includes and the quality of said content. A mod that adds content that a lot of people want to play with, and that is well-made, will generally gain quite a lot of traction, though it can take some time. A mod that adds content that not many want or that has poorly made content, however, tends to fall to the wayside. That's also why the number of follows don't necessarily mean a lot either; yes, having a lot of follows is generally a good thing, but if there's not a high download count to go with it, it tends to indicate that people are interested in watching potential development but not really interested in actually playing with the mod

For sure, add to that to I think library/framework-mods benefit more from total download count that aggregate score or endorsements, mainly because few people will download a library or supporting mod independently of its dependents. Combining both gives a good picture of what is a popular and well-liked mod, separately they tell very different stories (general consensus on content quality for ratings/endorsement vs role as a dependency). As to ModDB, I do like that it does show download count per version, it's a useful stat for players especially if mod-updates break other dependent mods or a player wants to track popularity over time for lesser-updated mods

Posted (edited)

If people don't like AI generated mods, it's simple... don't download it. Why is everyone wasting time on the subject? No one is forcing you to use them.  

 

I'm not going to use them, but I'm not going to stop anyone else from using them. It's their decision, not mine.

 

There does seem to be a lot of people on a mission to stop anyone else from using them. And I can't help but wonder why. 

Edited by KahvozeinsFang
  • Like 1
Posted (edited)
On 11/16/2026 at 10:16 PM, KahvozeinsFang said:

If people don't like AI generated mods, it's simple... don't download it. Why is everyone wasting time on the subject? No one is forcing you to use them.  

 

I'm not going to use them, but I'm not going to stop anyone else from using them. It's their decision, not mine.

 

There does seem to be a lot of people on a mission to stop anyone else from using them. And I can't help but wonder why. 

the logic goes like this (I do not endorse this logic, its just the logic being used)

1. AI mods are not good and people do not want them

2. AI mods are 'all over the place' in the top mods list.

So somehow those AI mods got to top of the list by being not good and not something people want.

so apparently everyone is downloading and using mods that they do not want to use, again, how that works I do not know.

I would assume if there is a mod most people do not want then it would fall lower on the list and eventually into obscurity and become a non-issue.

I do however think its fine to add a 'AI Mod' filter  so that I can find the AI mods faster :)

 

Edited by CastIronFabric
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.