CastIronFabric Posted November 12 Report Posted November 12 4 minutes ago, Teh Pizza Lady said: That is the finding, and it is sitting in a reply to someone who is not going to read it. It also predicts something testable about the database rather than about AI: a mod with a public repo and an author who has already survived a release is the better bet, label or no label. If that still holds at 1.23, then the thing worth putting on a mod page is the repo link, not the AI tag. That is a suggestion the moderators can act on without settling the ethics question at all. This is the most unusual thing in the thread and it went past everyone. You have written down what you will check and how, before the data exists, which makes your claim the only one in here that can lose. So ask the people who are certain for their number now. What share of the AI mods that face 1.23 will still be updated six months after it, and what result would make them say the vibe was wrong. Anyone who writes a number gets taken seriously in January. Anyone who does not has told you it is a preference, which is allowed, but a preference is something they need to handle on their own end instead of requiring you or someone else to cater to them, IMO. Nobody has disagreed with your update rates except one person, and they are asking for a name list rather than a number. Everyone else is answering the ethics question, which is about what belongs on the database, and that is a decision for the people who run it, which is a stance I've shared before in other threads. No survival curves are great and they're interesting data, but the only thing that matters is what the official people in charge think and they've been loudly quiet about it. One thing before you go back to the data. You have spent today answering the same three dissenters. Your supporters need some love, too. From your data it looks like half of the mods posted get dropped at every game release, and always have. That is not a story about AI. That is a story about volunteers not finishing the job. One need look no further than the endless variety of stick mods that have been abandoned with every game update for concrete proof of that statement. That's the joke. The answer for a list of names was provided by the person you are responding to and the list is as follows, although I question the accuracy of that list Carry On, Alchemy and Pet AI
CastIronFabric Posted November 12 Report Posted November 12 13 hours ago, Wick said: Steam suffers and will increasingly suffer more from AI slop games. I get your AI mod flood for the Mod DB. I really do. I'm also not fond of AI-written descriptions, thumbnails etc., holy shit just show an ingame pic of your implemented shit and write 3-4 sentences, even if its bad. But don't make a 200 line long AI summary for it. One should be able to do so. Even when done mostly by AI, this shows at least you know what you prompted. why is it that people fundamentally do not believe that 'Top' lists likely contain things people want rather than things people do not want? Why is that?
Demoncyborg Posted November 12 Report Posted November 12 12 hours ago, Wondiws98 said: Just in case you aren't aware. This what you are using to make mods: \ Oh no politics! Sorry. Im just gonna be a pedant here, not interested in responding to the tornado of an AI conversation and likely will leave my two cents and ghost this thread, but data centers have been around long before LLMS too, and I'm just interested in showing some the semantics. the one you posted specifically here is an AWS center, which does cloud hosting as well as LLM infrastructure. I think it's important that people know that traditionally, Data centers do more than just pump out endless heat and suck endless energy purely for AI. Places like this have been hosting cloud services, streaming services, and plenty of personal and commercial use servers for a long time too! We have data centers to thank for a lot of web services that many of us might use daily. actually, doing a little digging, this very forum is hosted with AWS too, so you are using it too! yes, i know there are purely purpose-built AI data centers that have a different demands as far as energy intake and cooling goes, but just wanted to mention that this one you chose doesn't do just that. 3 2
CastIronFabric Posted November 12 Report Posted November 12 (edited) 6 minutes ago, Danko Sedin said: I am saying that AI has been used in their development. Are you following our discussion or just fool around? Have you take a look into repo of CarryOn? like I said, Carry On mod has been around far longer than the topic of 'AI mods' so is this a retroactive problem now? it was some problem in the past but yet nobody talked about it? or are you saying everyone is downloading a bad AI mod that is Carry On and they just do not understand that they are using slop that is actually bad, they just think its good. You think Carry On mod should be removed from ModDB? Edited November 12 by CastIronFabric
Danko Sedin Posted November 12 Author Report Posted November 12 5 minutes ago, Teh Pizza Lady said: From your data it looks like half of the mods posted get dropped at every game release, and always have. That is not a story about AI. That is a story about volunteers not finishing the job. One need look no further than the endless variety of stick mods that have been abandoned with every game update for concrete proof of that statement. Yes, only half get updates after release, and this is what has been a thing before a AI. Also, last couple of releases we had an x2 of author per release. In another words - every release there is a 50/50 split between veterans and newbies. It is kinda crazy.
Wondiws98 Posted November 12 Report Posted November 12 (edited) Just woke up. Really don't feel like debating honestly. All I wanted to do was share my opinion on a topic that hits too close to home. I just feel like we are losing something important by allowing AI slop on the Mod DB. If people doesn't feel the same. That's ok. I don't like it but that's how it is. I would have at least voiced my concern. (and turned into a potter in the process) Edited November 12 by Wondiws98
CastIronFabric Posted November 12 Report Posted November 12 (edited) 11 minutes ago, Danko Sedin said: Yes, only half get updates after release, and this is what has been a thing before a AI. Also, last couple of releases we had an x2 of author per release. In another words - every release there is a 50/50 split between veterans and newbies. It is kinda crazy. I do not want to put words in your mouth but it sounds like you saying mods such as Carry On and Alchemy are a problem. How you are hesitant about the mod database as it currently stands while at the same time do enough research to know how these specific mods are built I do not know, I can only speculate. However, if given your in depth research into these top mods leaves you questioning using mods then you should indeed role with your gut. However, context is important here, people like Carry On mod, people like Alchemy. You might think they are terrible mods because its 'made with AI' but most people like them. Finally, I do fully understand what this exercise actually is, I just do not understand the point. moving on/ Edited November 12 by CastIronFabric
Danko Sedin Posted November 12 Author Report Posted November 12 7 minutes ago, CastIronFabric said: like I said, Carry On mod has been around far longer than the topic of 'AI mods' so is this a retroactive problem now? it was some problem in the past but yet nobody talked about it? or are you saying everyone is downloading a bad AI mod that is Carry On and they just do not understand that they are using slop that is actually bad, they just think its good. You think Carry On mod should be removed from ModDB? Yes, it has been a long time there and it was PURE. And now author of it is using a modern tool for mundane job. I don't have a problem with it. But some people do(some of them already said that in this thread). I think I wouldn't reply again to you. I feel like I am wondering in circles
Danko Sedin Posted November 12 Author Report Posted November 12 18 minutes ago, Wondiws98 said: All I wanted to do was share my opinion on a topic that hits too close to home. Thank you for opinion. I am sorry that my topic hit that hard. If you really-really want to fight against data-centers - you should support Ukrainian army. Our guys already burned some of them, and definitely will burn some more. 1
Teh Pizza Lady Posted November 12 Report Posted November 12 13 minutes ago, Danko Sedin said: now author of it is using a modern tool for mundane job Oh, yep, there it is in the .gitignore file... oh well, moving on. 25 minutes ago, Danko Sedin said: Yes, only half get updates after release, and this is what has been a thing before a AI. Also, last couple of releases we had an x2 of author per release. In another words - every release there is a 50/50 split between veterans and newbies. It is kinda crazy. AI made mod-making more accessible, even more-so since the modding API is fully documented online and crawlable by bots and the source code for the game is public. Now what you're seeing is output from people with a vision but not the time or skills to make it happen quickly. Of course I am going to be biased. I am also a mod author, but I'm also a programmer in my day job. I've done things the hard way for years, now I can relax and actually enjoy my craft. There will always be people who can't create who will always want to destroy what others have made to feel better about themselves, but in the end, they will fail to achieve even that because destruction of something nice always brings a net negative into the environment. Personally I'm going to go back to work and enjoy my job and solving problems with the help of AI faster than I could without it. Then in roughly 8 hours I'm going to log off and slap an AI tool around and tell it to work on the next phase of my mod development because I've been procrastinating. 1 minute ago, Danko Sedin said: If you really-really want to fight against data-centers - you should support Ukrainian army. Our guys already burned some of them, and definitely will burn some more. I just want RAM and GPUs to be affordable again. Some of us have PCs that are sorely in need of upgrades! >_< 1
Zaph42nd Posted November 12 Report Posted November 12 36 minutes ago, Danko Sedin said: Yes, only half get updates after release, and this is what has been a thing before a AI. Also, last couple of releases we had an x2 of author per release. In another words - every release there is a 50/50 split between veterans and newbies. It is kinda crazy. Exactly, even before AI the timing, release, and updating of mods has always been variable with most new projects usually getting abandoned after a few weeks (which makes sense seeing as maintaining a mod can be annoying). AI in this case can help accelerate version-updating and debugging, which is what I suspect most major mods are using AI to do (since making new content with AI would place one under scrutiny). I still think it's good to have tagged distinctions on AI's usage, AI-assisted (coding) and AI developed (assets, code, and other components) tags would help users who are opposed to AI mods
CastIronFabric Posted November 12 Report Posted November 12 (edited) 47 minutes ago, Danko Sedin said: Yes, it has been a long time there and it was PURE. And now author of it is using a modern tool for mundane job. I don't have a problem with it. But some people do(some of them already said that in this thread). I think I wouldn't reply again to you. I feel like I am wondering in circles Its Carry on Mod, its not like its Better Ruins. It does effectively one thing and has done that one thing for ages so what exact feature are you talking about specifically? Regardless though, people like it. Good luck trying to convince people that Carry On Mod is a problem and that they are all wrong for using it. more importantly why I am even engaging in this Edited November 12 by CastIronFabric
LadyWYT Posted November 12 Report Posted November 12 6 hours ago, MKMoose said: I find that outright not allowing a mod to be released without community endorsement is an issue not because of mob rule, but because it may make it difficult for new authors and niche utility mods to get approved without having to ask people to help out, which can be a significant barrier to entry. One thing that I've never understood, though, is why the Mod DB doesn't have some kind of a like/dislike, rating or review feature. Potentially community tags as well. Can they be exploited in some capacity? Sure... but nearly every single distribution site of any kind provides some way to rate whatever it's distributing, as that is a useful way for the community to self-moderate and inform others of the quality of the content and any of a number of issues. The Mod DB currently has some methods for this, but they are very limited and not dedicated strictly to review or tagging which makes them much less useful in practice. It's something I lumped under the "mob rule" umbrella for the sake of keeping my post brief instead of getting too longwinded, in addition to the fact that it's still a simple majority getting to decide who gets to post mods and who doesn't. So yeah, beginner mod authors are going to end up getting booted off the database in most cases, because the sad reality is that many "beginner mods" aren't going to be high quality products. Incidentally, that's also why I think the argument of banning AI mods in the name of quality is a really bad one--if you're going to argue for that ban for the sake of quality, then every mod needs to be held to the same standards, regardless of what tools produced it. More tags is the best option I've seen so far, though I'm not sure about community tags being such a good idea. Maybe a set of reactions like we have on the forums instead, so that users can leave positive reactions on the mods they enjoyed and negative on the mods they didn't like so much. There's still the risk of mods getting brigaded, however, I think reactions are a little easier to deal with than tag abuse. Regarding more tags in general, that would definitely make content easier to find and filter, and likely also push more authors to be more diligent about tagging their stuff so they're actually reaching their desired audience instead of falling to the wayside.
Danko Sedin Posted November 12 Author Report Posted November 12 45 minutes ago, Teh Pizza Lady said: AI made mod-making more accessible, even more-so since the modding API is fully documented online and crawlable by bots and the source code for the game is public. After tons of videos like "VS vs Minecraft" I've had an impression that Tyron built game to be modable by anyone. I was surprised, that he actually didn't say that anywhere. Most correct statement would be - VS was built in moding in mind. AI tools just took a step from other side and closed the gap ))) Being able to build something to play with, and share it with friends - is awesome!
CastIronFabric Posted November 12 Report Posted November 12 20 minutes ago, LadyWYT said: It's something I lumped under the "mob rule" umbrella for the sake of keeping my post brief instead of getting too longwinded, in addition to the fact that it's still a simple majority getting to decide who gets to post mods and who doesn't. So yeah, beginner mod authors are going to end up getting booted off the database in most cases, because the sad reality is that many "beginner mods" aren't going to be high quality products. Incidentally, that's also why I think the argument of banning AI mods in the name of quality is a really bad one--if you're going to argue for that ban for the sake of quality, then every mod needs to be held to the same standards, regardless of what tools produced it. More tags is the best option I've seen so far, though I'm not sure about community tags being such a good idea. Maybe a set of reactions like we have on the forums instead, so that users can leave positive reactions on the mods they enjoyed and negative on the mods they didn't like so much. There's still the risk of mods getting brigaded, however, I think reactions are a little easier to deal with than tag abuse. Regarding more tags in general, that would definitely make content easier to find and filter, and likely also push more authors to be more diligent about tagging their stuff so they're actually reaching their desired audience instead of falling to the wayside. Agreed. and regarding Community Tags, Steam is a good example of how sideways it goes. 'Games like this' for example are almost always all over the map, shooters getting labeled as life sims. With that said, its contradictory logic on my part to suggest 'Top' lists actually do reflect what people want and that actually does seem to work rather well in a lot of systems but community tagging does not. Perhaps because a very small minority of people actually tag
Teh Pizza Lady Posted November 12 Report Posted November 12 1 hour ago, CastIronFabric said: shooters getting labeled as life sims. Obvious trolls poisoning the tags.
VANTABlack2000 Posted November 12 Report Posted November 12 5 hours ago, Danko Sedin said: As a professional programmer I found it very annoying when people talk about code as art, learn by yourself, but can't learn git and GitHub. It is irresponsible in regards for community to do such things, and we tolerate it as nothing. Also, you trust that mod code doesn't do nothing malicious to you in case of closed sources mods is kinda brave. Code need to be published. Even if its art. You are making A LOT of assumptions here. 1. I literally studied Computer Science and though I don't do software development as a job because I hate corporations and all the jobs now either require insane amounts of experience or to use Claude or whatever which I have laid out my problems with I DO know how to code and I DO know how to use Git and GitHub. 2. YOU MADE the correlation between Code being art, and code being needing to be published. If this is a mod argument and saying that the code needs to be published to make sure it's not malicious OF COURSE I agree with you because there was LITERALLY A DRAMA FOR THIS GAME about code being considered malicious by some not too long ago. What at this point do you just assume I don't know what I am talking about in the slightest because I am against AI? I am both a programmer and an artist that IS possible. Part of the reason I hate AI is because I KNOW what goes on behind the curtain and I know the result of it. GenAI like ChatGPT was trained by scraping people's works off the internet at mass scale to generate whatever it wants removing people's jobs and removing the soul from the art and just making an image that is the average of what it scraped. It is the average of everything it scraped because it all boils down to WEIGHTS it looks at the weights of what most likely fits the prompt and makes something based off of it. Also as for your image there is more to it than JUST know this equation. Color theory has to be used for picking the colors of the image you made as well. Not to mention does that equation make the background too? You may not consider stealing, but I am sure there are MANY artists like me that do when the purpose of using their art without their permission is to replace them and corrupt their craft like I outlined above. Mods if I am getting too heated in this let me know because naturally AI is a very touchy subject for me.
Danko Sedin Posted November 12 Author Report Posted November 12 31 minutes ago, VANTABlack2000 said: You are making A LOT of assumptions here. 1. I literally studied Computer Science and though I don't do software development as a job because I hate corporations and all the jobs now either require insane amounts of experience or to use Claude or whatever which I have laid out my problems with I DO know how to code and I DO know how to use Git and GitHub. 2. YOU MADE the correlation between Code being art, and code being needing to be published. If this is a mod argument and saying that the code needs to be published to make sure it's not malicious OF COURSE I agree with you because there was LITERALLY A DRAMA FOR THIS GAME about code being considered malicious by some not too long ago. What at this point do you just assume I don't know what I am talking about in the slightest because I am against AI? I am both a programmer and an artist that IS possible. Part of the reason I hate AI is because I KNOW what goes on behind the curtain and I know the result of it. GenAI like ChatGPT was trained by scraping people's works off the internet at mass scale to generate whatever it wants removing people's jobs and removing the soul from the art and just making an image that is the average of what it scraped. It is the average of everything it scraped because it all boils down to WEIGHTS it looks at the weights of what most likely fits the prompt and makes something based off of it. Also as for your image there is more to it than JUST know this equation. Color theory has to be used for picking the colors of the image you made as well. Not to mention does that equation make the background too? You may not consider stealing, but I am sure there are MANY artists like me that do when the purpose of using their art without their permission is to replace them and corrupt their craft like I outlined above. Mods if I am getting too heated in this let me know because naturally AI is a very touchy subject for me. Ok, now you can feel what it like to be assumed of something. I am sorry that I offended your feelings. The point I was making though is - no matter how picky you can be there always would be someone who could be more pickier than you. You mastered 3 areas? What about marketing?! Do you use CI to build your mod? What about writing code in only true style - functional?! It is never ever ending journey to learn something. Even for people who use AI. They learning AI, for example. Or game design, whatever. I can't share you feeling about code as art for one simple reason. I never seen somebody who wrote a line of code, stand back and said "The best line of code in my life". For me, anything written is a piece of sheet as soon as it written. Just because I always can do better. I think real reason why people feel that AI steals something from them(and being very protective of their code) - because AI made implementation cheap, but ideas valuable and in the same time very fragile. Before AI idea would cost almost nothing - you need to create it before it will obtain value. And code was a proof of creation. Now, when you can create whatever you want you need to want something cool at first place. Idea become something valuable, because you can implement it relatively cheap. And also other people can stole your idea and create something of their own. In almost all countries law will agree that their creation is their, and you wouldn't get anything from your idea. This is sad reality. As for the image - equation is enough. Color for this image usually defined by numbers of hopes that point need to go out of specific area. It is a beautiful Mandelbrot set if you want to know more about it.
VANTABlack2000 Posted November 12 Report Posted November 12 50 minutes ago, Danko Sedin said: Ok, now you can feel what it like to be assumed of something. I am sorry that I offended your feelings. The point I was making though is - no matter how picky you can be there always would be someone who could be more pickier than you. You mastered 3 areas? What about marketing?! Do you use CI to build your mod? What about writing code in only true style - functional?! It is never ever ending journey to learn something. Even for people who use AI. They learning AI, for example. Or game design, whatever. I can't share you feeling about code as art for one simple reason. I never seen somebody who wrote a line of code, stand back and said "The best line of code in my life". For me, anything written is a piece of sheet as soon as it written. Just because I always can do better. I think real reason why people feel that AI steals something from them(and being very protective of their code) - because AI made implementation cheap, but ideas valuable and in the same time very fragile. Before AI idea would cost almost nothing - you need to create it before it will obtain value. And code was a proof of creation. Now, when you can create whatever you want you need to want something cool at first place. Idea become something valuable, because you can implement it relatively cheap. And also other people can stole your idea and create something of their own. In almost all countries law will agree that their creation is their, and you wouldn't get anything from your idea. This is sad reality. As for the image - equation is enough. Color for this image usually defined by numbers of hopes that point need to go out of specific area. It is a beautiful Mandelbrot set if you want to know more about it. I well aware it's a never ending journey. Even just learning coding it's a never ending journey because things are always getting updated and there's so many languages to learn. For some you may be right about why they hate AI. For ME it's a few things 1. Because I value the effort and emotion put into art and AI has no concept of emotion and it's very little effort to just write a prompt and get it done. 2. Because I believe in people's ability to learn and there have been many studies like this one https://www.microsoft.com/en-us/research/publication/the-impact-of-generative-ai-on-critical-thinking-self-reported-reductions-in-cognitive-effort-and-confidence-effects-from-a-survey-of-knowledge-workers/ that say using AI leads to decreased critical thinking skills. 3. As I have said before I am not a huge fan of corporations, so I really don't like the idea of outsourcing your intelligence to a big corporation hyping all this up like OpenAI or Anthropic. 4. A lot AI use leads people to believe THEY made a thing when really it was the AI that took all the knowledge and made the program they really didn't DO much of anything it was the AI that did most of it and as outlined above it did it using the code of actual people in most cases without any attribution to themselves. the AI did most of the work and the person using it takes most of the credit in a lot of cases. 5. I have studied and made Ai and Machine Learning algorithms, so I know how basic AI works even if I don't know entirely how LLMs work I know enough of the basics to get the idea. I also know that there are things AI is better being used for and things that would be better off not being focused on. For example where is all the data analysis for studying weather patterns or trying to cure diseases instead of "Hey AI can you make this game for me because I don't feel like learning how to do it myself?" All of this is leading people using AI to act like they are better than people actually making their own art and pushing actual artists down which as AI becomes more prominent has a MAJOR effect on the mental health of artists like me, so yes there are many reasons people hate AI and doesn't boil down to "Well now people can do things cheap" which mind you is false when AI gets more expensive to use because of not only computer costs, but the cost of AI subscriptions or token usage goes up as well and making things mostly takes time whenever there is FOSS like Krita, Blender, and Godot to make it free to have your own programs. All it takes is time to learn. Then again a lot of people pushing AI love to think they are so smart and everyone else has no idea what they are talking about. AI is being used in so many places to push out people who are actually putting their heart and soul into projects and people are going "Well AI did it just as well, so use it or get left behind" I see my code as art because I know the effort it took to make it. I know I can do better and I STRIVE to do better, but that doesn't diminish all the work that went into me making my code. The latest example of me doing Art, Programming, and Music (Though the music is a cover of another song in Pico8 and I never say it's not) is my Pico8 game https://www.lexaloffle.com/bbs/?tid=160202 if you have Pico8 you can analyze the game yourself to learn how to do things on your own too. Knowing you can do better does mean that what you make isn't art. Again sorry mods for the walls of text and getting heated, but this is a topic that touches a nerve for multiple reasons. I could go on MANY rants, but needless to say there is a reason I don't want to support AI in the slightest. This will be my last post on the topic because at this point I don't think the conversation is being had in good faith.
Zaph42nd Posted November 12 Report Posted November 12 (edited) 11 hours ago, MKMoose said: One thing that I've never understood, though, is why the Mod DB doesn't have some kind of a like/dislike, rating or review feature. Potentially community tags as well. Can they be exploited in some capacity? Sure... but nearly every single distribution site of any kind provides some way to rate whatever it's distributing, as that is a useful way for the community to self-moderate and inform others of the quality of the content and any of a number of issues. The Mod DB currently has some methods for this, but they are very limited and not dedicated strictly to review or tagging which makes them much less useful in practice My thoughts as well, user/author tagging and user rating systems would probably be ideal since a vetting/review process and popular/highly downloaded mods would likely be reflected by a higher average rating. Really I'd like to see some features NexusMods does added to ModDB, that is: search excluding/including tags and show downloads + rating/endorsement #s trends. Those features alone would make it much easier to control/customize ModDB experience which I think could help in more ways than one.... Of course, still will need moderation and all but that's pretty standard. Any vetting system would probably run into the issue of time + added moderation demands, meaning new authors would be at a disadvantage and there'd be fewer mods available hence against the idea of a vetting system determining ability to publish on ModDB (but not against some way of aggregating user opinion) Edited November 12 by Zaph42nd Clarifying on vetting
Teh Pizza Lady Posted November 12 Report Posted November 12 22 minutes ago, Zaph42nd said: My thoughts as well, user/author tagging and user rating systems would probably be ideal since a vetting/review process and popular/highly downloaded mods would likely be reflected by a higher average rating. Really I'd like to see some features NexusMods does added to ModDB, that is: search excluding/including tags and show downloads + rating/endorsement #s trends. Those features alone would make it much easier to control/customize ModDB experience which I think could help in more ways than one.... Of course, still will need moderation and all but that's pretty standard. Any vetting system would probably run into the issue of time + added moderation demands, meaning new authors would be at a disadvantage and there'd be fewer mods available What problems does this solve and how exactly are they problems? Vetting who can post to the ModDB sounds like mob rule unless you want Anego to do it and they already do. They are very consistent in their removal of bad actors from the site and preventing troublemakers from interacting with others.
Zaph42nd Posted November 12 Report Posted November 12 7 minutes ago, Teh Pizza Lady said: What problems does this solve and how exactly are they problems? Vetting who can post to the ModDB sounds like mob rule unless you want Anego to do it and they already do. They are very consistent in their removal of bad actors from the site and preventing troublemakers from interacting with others. More just filtering/adding more functionality to searching which would be a nice-touch. As for a vetting system, not arguing for that since it is objectively a poor idea (and hopefully my post made that clear), but I do think some form of an endorsement/rating system would be a nicety (although not essential)
Danko Sedin Posted November 12 Author Report Posted November 12 1 hour ago, VANTABlack2000 said: This will be my last post on the topic because at this point I don't think the conversation is being had in good faith. I am sorry for that feeling. I see your position as an ethic, so I accept that it is something I can't change and wouldn't try. But I want to understand a background of it, and you gave an excellent description. I am grateful to you for that. And I was trying to give my background of my ethical position as well, I am sorry if it was like adding gas to the fire.
ArgentLuna Posted November 12 Report Posted November 12 As long as its flagged as being made with AI so that the people who don't wish to use it can avoid it, otherwise its a slippery slope of dictating who can what on a page meant for people who are sharing their alterations to this game (which is itself three mods in a trenchcoat) 2
Teh Pizza Lady Posted November 13 Report Posted November 13 3 hours ago, Zaph42nd said: More just filtering/adding more functionality to searching which would be a nice-touch. As for a vetting system, not arguing for that since it is objectively a poor idea (and hopefully my post made that clear), but I do think some form of an endorsement/rating system would be a nicety (although not essential) Endorsements and ratings I can see. Download count isn't really indicative of good quality... but new mods that get a lot of downloads and become popular quickly will suffer from not having as many endorsements. So how would you quantify something like that? Not you specifically but it's a problem that can't ever be solved because it relies on two things: Human involvement beyond your control Honesty
Recommended Posts