Jump to content

Recommended Posts

Posted
35 minutes ago, LickMYLiver said:

Essentially I'm here to ask this, what guarantees are there that Maltiez won't cause trouble in the future?

I would think that Maltiez getting removed from the Discord server, banned from the Mod DB and having all code contributions monitored particularly carefully would be enough of a guarantee.

And do keep in mind that the standard code review process makes it nearly impossible for malicious code to slip through, especially given that Maltiez is primarily tasked with mod API programming where it is relatively easy to notice suspicious code that doesn't do what it advertises.

If someone for whatever reason cannot bring themselves to trust the devs, then no guarantee will be absolute for them. Let's say that Maltiez gets fired - but oh no, what if they make a new account and upload malware onto the Mod DB? If Maltiez wanted to do actual damage, then whatever happens with his position at Anego is virtually irrelevant to what he can and has always been able to do behind their back - and in fact he had been able to do much more damage before he lost access to all of his mods, given that mods are not being carefully scanned by the devs. Firing Maltiez would be more about virtue signalling than about preventing any kind of risks, and actual risk prevention would be better done by implementing new features for the Mod DB.

 

1 hour ago, LickMYLiver said:

Because of his actions he has left a stain on the reputation of the development team, and its one that won't go away any time soon.

The vast majority of that stain has been created by an emotion-driven mob spreading misinformation about a topic that most people do not understand at a sufficient level to assume an educated stance on it. It really infuriates me how many people I've seen misinformed or tricked and as a result genuinely worried that their PC might have been infected with malware. The actual risk of the supposedly "malicious" code was smaller than that of a poorly-made mod crashing a server, or of Windows' SAC silently blocking loading of DLLs causing frequent crashes in VS and plenty of other apps.

That stain could have been largely prevented, but the prevention lies primarily in a better-prepared moderation and community management team which bears little to no relation with the source of the drama itself. Tyron has promised improvements on that front.

 

1 hour ago, LickMYLiver said:

I love this game, I want to keep on playing this wonderful game, but if this keep broiling under the surface then I can't keep doing so in good faith.

What would let you keep playing in good faith? Given that you're seemingly not satisfied by:

  • Malt's punishment (removed from the Discord server, banned from the Mod DB),
  • Malt's contributions being monitored more carefully,
  • Tyron's apology,
  • clear acknowledgement of specific mistakes made by Anego,
  • training of the moderation team to better handle similar situations in the future.
  • Like 14
  • Thanks 2
Posted

What guarantees are there that other members of the dev team won't cause trouble in the future? Do you want a community council to cross-reference every developer's twitter accounts with their geographic coordinates to see how closely they live to the AI data centers being built, and if they are within 500km, they should be removed from the dev team? 

Obviously, Maltieze is still on the dev team because he provides value to the company, and product. The removal of people from the dev team is up to the discretion of Anego Studios, and clearly you're unhappy that you can't make the decision to condemn him, while standing outside the company, not being HR, or having much to reference about his employment.

Is the thought process here that Malitez is sneakily rubbing his hands together, thinking about the best way to write code to crash your game when you run the mods he doesn't like? And that every other employ at Anego is blind to it or supportive? And that there's been absolutely no changes to procedures since the controversy happened?

I find it a bit annoying that you're framing Anego as le cinnamon roll too good for this world, funded entirely by the grassroots and panhandling. And that a minor controversy is going to kill the company unless they reverse course. I think it's a much smaller controversy that you're trying to emphasize it to be, just because you're upset with the way it's been handled.

  • Like 3
  • Cookie time 1
Posted
1 hour ago, The Lerf said:

What guarantees are there that other members of the dev team won't cause trouble in the future? Do you want a community council to cross-reference every developer's twitter accounts with their geographic coordinates to see how closely they live to the AI data centers being built, and if they are within 500km, they should be removed from the dev team? 

Obviously, Maltieze is still on the dev team because he provides value to the company, and product. The removal of people from the dev team is up to the discretion of Anego Studios, and clearly you're unhappy that you can't make the decision to condemn him, while standing outside the company, not being HR, or having much to reference about his employment.

Is the thought process here that Malitez is sneakily rubbing his hands together, thinking about the best way to write code to crash your game when you run the mods he doesn't like? And that every other employ at Anego is blind to it or supportive? And that there's been absolutely no changes to procedures since the controversy happened?

I find it a bit annoying that you're framing Anego as le cinnamon roll too good for this world, funded entirely by the grassroots and panhandling. And that a minor controversy is going to kill the company unless they reverse course. I think it's a much smaller controversy that you're trying to emphasize it to be, just because you're upset with the way it's been handled.

Yeah that sounds about right. As someone who got caught up in the mob of all the Maltiez stuff that went on while I have some worries about him being on the dev team I trust Anego to make sure everything is good.

While there are some things I wish were done better like most info being on Discord or Social Media as opposed to the Forums I think everything is in a good spot when it comes to Maltiez.

At least personally if I were to not play the game anymore it wouldn't be the Maltiez situation that makes me quit. It does worry me a little bit that you need to login to Vintage Story in game to access it because I am the type of person who worries about servers shutting down or businesses just killing a game, but I trust Anego to not be that kind of dev. I am also not 100% sure how Anego is with GenAI/LLMs which is something that strikes a nerve with me, but again I trust Anego more than I do most studios.

The Maltiez drama mainly boils down to Anego doesn't know how to deal with dramas which is something they want to improve now, so like I said before I don't think it is the biggest issue for the studio especially since there is A LOT less talk about it than there was before. People still talk about it from time to time, but it's more of a "Yeah it happened, but it wasn't really that big of a deal" kind of thing now.

Posted
5 hours ago, LickMYLiver said:

Essentially I'm here to ask this, what guarantees are there that Maltiez won't cause trouble in the future?

Ultimately, there are none, same as there are no guarantees that any other member of the community itself, not just the dev community, couldn't someday make a mistake or otherwise snap and do something they really shouldn't. Regarding Maltiez specifically, Anego did what they needed to do to handle the situation as soon as they were fully aware of it, and did so in a manner they felt appropriate. That doesn't mean that everyone agreed with how it was handled, but I think it says a lot that Tyron issued refunds to those who asked and still allowed those players to keep their game licenses. At that point, players can choose to keep playing, or stop playing if they still aren't satisfied or don't trust the devs since I mean...it doesn't make sense to keep playing a game if you really believe the dev team can't be trusted at all.

  • Like 1
  • Thanks 2
Posted
1 hour ago, LadyWYT said:

Ultimately, there are none, same as there are no guarantees that any other member of the community itself, not just the dev community, couldn't someday make a mistake or otherwise snap and do something they really shouldn't. Regarding Maltiez specifically, Anego did what they needed to do to handle the situation as soon as they were fully aware of it, and did so in a manner they felt appropriate. That doesn't mean that everyone agreed with how it was handled, but I think it says a lot that Tyron issued refunds to those who asked and still allowed those players to keep their game licenses. At that point, players can choose to keep playing, or stop playing if they still aren't satisfied or don't trust the devs since I mean...it doesn't make sense to keep playing a game if you really believe the dev team can't be trusted at all.

I did forget they did that. That is a good way to kind of extend an olive branch since it does prove they aren't like other companies that would just remove all access to the game because of a refund.

Every since things smoothed over I have gotten the vibe from the whole thing that Anego just messed up because they haven't really had to DO something like this to my knowledge. They tried, but weren't the best at PR (Which is something they are trying to improve on now) which is understandable because it's not like they are a big studio like Microsoft who has whole departments dedicated to this kind of thing. I do still believe they want what is best for players not just trying to make their money like other studios would.

  • Like 2
Posted (edited)
11 hours ago, LickMYLiver said:

I love this game, I want to keep on playing this wonderful game, but if this keep broiling under the surface then I can't keep doing so in good faith. 

Then do it in bad faith and enjoy the game anyway.

Game will go on with or without you in the end and if your going let this minor (yes it really is minor in the scheme of things) thing stop you from having fun then OK whatever suits you.

Edited by ArgentLuna
  • Like 1
Posted
11 hours ago, VANTABlack2000 said:

which is understandable because it's not like they are a big studio like Microsoft who has whole departments dedicated to this kind of thing.

In fairness, while having a dedicated PR department does help handle messes with the public, it's not a guarantee that the situation will calm down. Microsoft is also a pretty good example of how a company can have a big PR department and still be on the public naughty list.

Posted
14 hours ago, VANTABlack2000 said:

Every since things smoothed over I have gotten the vibe from the whole thing that Anego just messed up because they haven't really had to DO something like this to my knowledge. They tried, but weren't the best at PR (Which is something they are trying to improve on now) which is understandable because it's not like they are a big studio like Microsoft who has whole departments dedicated to this kind of thing. I do still believe they want what is best for players not just trying to make their money like other studios would.

Same thoughts as well, I think the whole thing blew up and Anego wasn't prepared for it, but sometimes you learn how to handle drama and PR messes by having them happen.... I really doubt in the long term the controversy will yield much of anything and given how Anego has been giving the olive-branch (refunds, apologies, etc...), I think it shows that they learned their lesson and want to move on 

Posted
On 11/18/2026 at 1:14 AM, VANTABlack2000 said:

It does worry me a little bit that you need to login to Vintage Story in game to access it because I am the type of person who worries about servers shutting down or businesses just killing a game

Tyron has said that the very last update that VS will have is the removal of the authentication system when booting up the game, so i trust it.

  • Like 1
Posted
1 minute ago, Michaloid said:

Tyron has said that the very last update that VS will have is the removal of the authentication system when booting up the game, so i trust it.

AH see I haven't seen that statement, so I wasn't aware of that. That DOES give me even more trust in Tyron.

Posted
5 minutes ago, Michaloid said:

It's a pretty old statement, but i trust he'll uphold it in the end.

Considering things like Anego still letting people access the game after refunding I trust Tyron to uphold that statement more than I do most studios.

Posted
18 hours ago, Zaph42nd said:

Same thoughts as well, I think the whole thing blew up and Anego wasn't prepared for it, but sometimes you learn how to handle drama and PR messes by having them happen.... I really doubt in the long term the controversy will yield much of anything and given how Anego has been giving the olive-branch (refunds, apologies, etc...), I think it shows that they learned their lesson and want to move on 

In the grand scheme of things, i'm glad it happened. Because it was a wake up call to the entire team that they aren't a lil smol niche studio with few player counts anymore. So they decided that it was time to change things up. Moderation, their process, pr, everything.

Posted
On 11/18/2026 at 2:23 AM, ArgentLuna said:

Then do it in bad faith and enjoy the game anyway.

Game will go on with or without you in the end and if your going let this minor (yes it really is minor in the scheme of things) thing stop you from having fun then OK whatever suits you.

What a flippant way of handwaving what is legally classified as a federal crime because you want to bootlick to "own teh chetorz" or some other vapid, witless line of logic only capable of window licking sycophants.  If your only defensible position is to screech "JUS CONSOOM PRODUCT CHUD WE DON'T NEED YOU TO ANNONUNCE YUR LEVING", sincerely seek help.  Because what Maltiez did is not just a federal crime in the US, but all of the European Union.

  • Like 1
Posted
10 minutes ago, Teh Pizza Lady said:

HOW is this thread still alive?

Merged threads probably to keep things consistent/stop more threads from popping up. But at this point think the topic should be locked in my opinion (it's been a little over a month and a half at this point so most all of the drama should be done)

Posted
3 hours ago, Greznig said:

What a flippant way of handwaving what is legally classified as a federal crime because you want to bootlick to "own teh chetorz" or some other vapid, witless line of logic only capable of window licking sycophants.  If your only defensible position is to screech "JUS CONSOOM PRODUCT CHUD WE DON'T NEED YOU TO ANNONUNCE YUR LEVING", sincerely seek help.  Because what Maltiez did is not just a federal crime in the US, but all of the European Union.

no one is handwaving what he did, but the situation is over, he has been dealt with, the malware is gone, so there is no reason to continue worrying about it.

  • Like 4
Posted
1 hour ago, Greznig said:

"HE ADMITTED HE MADE A FUCKY WUCKY CHUD, HE EVEN APPOLOGIZED"

That isn’t what i said now is is.

1 hour ago, Greznig said:

And then there's the utter abomination of what Maltiez did, and what he had a problem with.

I know what he did, I’m not downplaying that.

1 hour ago, Greznig said:

He not only shouldn't be allowed near VS because of what he did,

He can't do anything like this on the dev team, someone would notice when they review his work.

1 hour ago, Greznig said:

I'm convinced he's being kept around because the dev team don't want to go through the work of developing the combat overhaul themselves.

Maltiez is not a developer of the combat update, he is only an advisor, his role in development is working on the modding API.

Posted (edited)

Dang it can't believe I've been baited back into this topic.

2 hours ago, Greznig said:

Then he's a bloody fucking moron who hasn't the faintest fucking grasp of programming, period.  End of story.  This is quite literally textbook C# - 101, learning how to program securely.  You don't just see securely written code and think "Oh man those fucking hackers man I'm going to fucking rape every one of those fucker's computers, EVERYBODY running secure code HAS to be a hackerman" without having the most minimal understanding of programming humanly possible.  Like, I cannot stress this enough, go take a C# class right fucking now, by week 5 you're learning how to program securely.  He's not incompetent, he's not just an idiot, he's dangerously stupid.

Why do you say "programming securely" as if it's a technique or skill rather than "obfuscation" which is a sparingly-used and rarely-useful post-processing technique that can be applied to any program? The only real use it has is slowing down reverse engineering and inspection of what you're doing. But in something like VS there's no point. Almost every line is a call to an API function that clearly advertises what you're doing.

Nobody's teaching obfuscation in programming classes. I sure wasn't teaching anyone how to obfuscate. Week 5 I was still trying to get them to wrap their heads around data types. Obfuscation isn't security. So much so that it's a meme in the literal sense. What would be the point of teaching basic beginners a technique with no use to them in the present and very limited utility in the future?

Edited by Diff
  • Like 1
Posted
2 hours ago, Greznig said:

"the malware is gone, so there is no reason to continue worrying about it."

"the malware is gone, so there is no reason to continue worrying about it."

"the MALWARE is gone, so there is NO REASON to continue worrying about it."

He shouldn't be allowed within a hundred miles of development because, and I hate to repeat myself but

The implication being if he's as incompetent professionally as he is programming

Then he's a bloody fucking moron who hasn't the faintest fucking grasp of programming, period.  End of story.  This is quite literally textbook C# - 101, learning how to program securely.  You don't just see securely written code and think "Oh man those fucking hackers man I'm going to fucking rape every one of those fucker's computers, EVERYBODY running secure code HAS to be a hackerman" without having the most minimal understanding of programming humanly possible.  Like, I cannot stress this enough, go take a C# class right fucking now, by week 5 you're learning how to program securely.  He's not incompetent, he's not just an idiot, he's dangerously stupid.

My brother in Christ, Maltiez did not bring down the entire US air traffic control network

He made a mod that made da gaem window close.

You seem super concerned over what your imagination says could have happened rather than what actually happened, to the point where your presenting yourself as a bit of a joke. Holy hell. Imagine this guy's reaction to someone who makes his sandwich wrong.

  • Haha 1
Posted
13 hours ago, The Lerf said:

My brother in Christ, Maltiez did not bring down the entire US air traffic control network

He made a mod that made da gaem window close.

You seem super concerned over what your imagination says could have happened rather than what actually happened, to the point where your presenting yourself as a bit of a joke. Holy hell. Imagine this guy's reaction to someone who makes his sandwich wrong.

"I didn't program MALWARE your honor, I simply stole their banking credentials"

Okay.

  • Like 1
Posted
14 hours ago, Diff said:

Why do you say "programming securely" as if it's a technique or skill rather than "obfuscation" which is a sparingly-used and rarely-useful post-processing technique that can be applied to any program?

Its okay you're wrong champ!  In C#, secure coding is a term we use to describe certain syntax usage that prevents outside users from passing in variables such as malign actors.  Part of secure programming as a broader policy, analogous to defensive programming, is actually obfuscation, which is used when you're running software that is publicly facing, that might potentially face a high degree of 3rd party tampering.  This is a technique often used in online games in order to further prevent hackers and cheaters from further manipulating data as a method of useful encryption.  

I'm sure you can imagine why its so silly for a goof ball like Maltiez to take such a amateurish exception with industry standard coding practices.

Both are used in professional environments that you are, by my estimation, unexperienced with.  But don't worry, one day, you too can be a professional programmer with the right education, experience, and willingness to learn.

  • Like 1
  • Wolf Bait 1
×
×
  • Create New...

Important Information

We have placed cookies on your device to help make this website better. You can adjust your cookie settings, otherwise we'll assume you're okay to continue.